Sunday, February 16, 2025

Heroism and Victimhood

 

There were two article at the Free Press this week about men and heroism. Both were well written, but one in particular misunderstood heroism in a way that is typical of out cultural milieu by its emphasis on sacrifice. It is an example of the present and recent tendency to glorify victims and victimhood, sometimes to the extent of an apparent inability to admire or care about much else. It shows up when politicians and media people try to say something nice about veterans and members of the armed forces. It is almost always some cliché about their sacrifice. Yet the real virtue is not sacrifice but valor – doing a tough, dangerous job with honor and fidelity at mortal risk. One can illustrate this with a simple thought experiment. If the men who stormed the beaches at Normandy on D-Day had gone ashore meek and unarmed and been slaughtered to a man while accomplishing nothing, their sacrifice would have been complete. Yet I doubt that reasonable people would have found that admirable or that Americans would rightly be commemorating their deeds eighty years later.


Heroes sometimes fail and sometimes suffer and die, but that is not what makes them heroic. The present day apotheosis of victims and victimhood is not only incompatible with heroism and the desire for the heroic. It is antithetical to them.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, December 05, 2022

Asking the Wrong Question

 Republicans like to complain about being treated unfairly by members of the traditional media. They often have good reasons for doing so, but, based on what I have seen in the news, today interviewers have been doing them a favor. Asking Republicans if they agree with Trump’s call to “terminate” the Constitution, allowed them to give the easy and probably honest answer that they do not. That is not the right question to be asking Republican politicians and their allies in the conservative media. The right question is “would you support a candidate for public office who called for overthrowing the Constitution of the United States, and if not does that include Donald Trump?” That is the question Republicans should have to answer and live with the consequences, one way or the other.

Labels: , , ,

Monday, March 14, 2022

War News


Some things about the war in Ukraine are obvious. The Russians are the aggressors, and the war is the fault of their dictator Putin. There is fighting on more than one front, and the Ukrainians have not been overrun. Many Ukrainian civilians have been killed, and many others have become refugees. Some things about the war are difficult or impossible to know accurately in the midst of the fighting, such as counts of casualties in both armies, the effectiveness of various weapons and tactics, the degree to which Russian controlled territory is actually under their control, how much and how effectively Ukrainian guerrillas are operating behind Russian positions, and so on. The fog of war is real, and it is well known that early reports on conflicts are often incomplete, tinged by propaganda, or even completely wrong. War correspondents in Ukraine have a difficult job.


The job of writers and journalists back in the United States is far easier, and one should expect better than what some are producing. There is a lot of ignorance and dishonesty out there – some of it about the war and some about the history and background. I have read more than one story reporting that the Germans’ decision to increase spending on defense is a departure from nearly eighty years of post World War II pacifism. The truth is that from the 1960s through the 1980s West Germany fielded the largest NATO army deployed in Europe and dropped its defenses after the fall of the Soviet Union less out of pacifism than a pragmatic opinion that the threat had disappeared. Other stories talk of the war in Ukraine as ending a seventy five year European order of peace and unity. The truth is that from 1947 to the fall of the Soviet Union what Europe had was not a peaceful order but an armed truce between hostile forces facing each other across the iron curtain. A peaceful European order goes back only about thirty years, and even then one has to ignore a few things in the Balkans, Crimea, and eastern Ukraine. Various political hacks in the traditional media try to blame the war for price inflation in the United States, ignoring the fact that the rate of price inflation was high and climbing before the Russians invaded Ukraine, and the fact that under both Trump and Biden, the US government manufactured money at inflationary rates.


There is also worse. Various people, mainly Trumpists including Trump and anti-American leftists, seem to have a soft spot for Putin. One can believe that Biden has handled things badly or that America should avoid pushing Russia into becoming a client state of China or that admitting Ukraine to NATO would be a mistake or simply that this should not be our fight, without becoming an apologist for or fan of what the Russians are doing.





Labels: , , ,

Monday, May 31, 2021

Memorial Day

Several years ago on a trip we were at one of the national military parks on Memorial Day and saw the flags at the graves at the cemetery there.  It was something to see.

Memoria Day is a holiday to honor and remember the men and recently women in the armed forces who fought for this country and didn’t make it back.  Americans should remember what we are honoring them for – valor, courage, perseverance, proper patriotism, and steadfastness and fidelity to duty in the face of danger which proved fatal.

Doing so is especially important these days with much of the traditional media in the hands of leftists. From the 1960s through the 1980s American leftists generally publicly despised and demeaned the armed forces. That turned out poorly for them politically, and in recent times they have tried to give an impression in pubic of supporting people in uniform and honoring the dead from America’s wars. Since many  leftists generally speak well of people other than themselves only when they can represent them as members of a class of victims, and as they are unwilling to speak of (and perhaps unable to appreciate or even understand) the qualities mentioned above, they have settled on sacrifice as what they will declare as the praiseworthy thing about the honored dead.

Most conservatives and other thoughtless people in the media have gone along. They shouldn’t have. It is wrong in fact as a simple thought experiment shows. If sacrifice is the criterion, one would have to have more respect for an imagined invasion by soldiers at Normandy or marines on Iwo who marched ashore unarmed and got slaughtered to a man producing a total sacrifice than for the brave men, survivors and fallen, who fought those battles.  It also shortchanges those Memorial Day honors by ignoring or dismissing their quality of character and martial virtues.  It skips over the importance of what they fought for since one can sacrifice for anything. That makes it harder for young people to understand that from these honored dead they should take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion. Lincoln understood. The political and media characters these days don’t.  

Labels: , , ,

Sunday, March 14, 2021

Cuomo's Two Troubles

 Governor Andrew Cuomo is in political trouble this week for a couple of reasons. He sent people with active cases  of Covid back to nursing homes leading  to the infection and deaths of thousands of people, lied about the number of people who died, and got caught in his lie. He also has been accused by several women of groping or sexually harassing them. Some organizations are covering both stories, but many people in the traditional media are reporting on the second story and ignoring the first. Almost all Democrat Party politicians are doing the same.

At first that must seem odd. Boorish remarks toward women and a case or two of unwanted grabbing are bad things, but they are so far less bad than negligently killing people and lying about it as to make them almost irrelevant in judging the man and his fitness to stay in office.  Yet Democrats and their public relations people in the traditional media are behaving as though the reverse were true.

I can think of a couple of reasons why. One is the desire to maintain and stick to the theme that Democrat governors and officials uniformly handled the epidemic wisely and effectively while Republicans did not.  Telling the truth about Cuomo’s failure would be implicitly admitting  the story was false and might lead to having to face doubts about the behavior of Newsom, Whitmer, and various others and even to questions about whether some of the decrees and power grabs were necessary or even productive.

Another reason might be simple embarrassment. Throughout the first months of the epidemic Democrat politicians and people in the traditional media treated Cuomo as a hero and near genius for his handling of it. They gave him awards and touted him as the obvious relief pitcher to be held ready to step in as their candidate for president in case Biden’s mental decline became too obvious to hide.   One can see how it might be a little deflating to have to admit what he was and did. It also might make cynical people wonder whether they can trusted to be accurate about anything political.  

Of course both of those guesses make the charitable assumption that they are suppressing the story only for reasons of expediency and not because they  really believe the killing of to them insignificant old people is less an offence than rudely  inconveniencing a few women of a quality and type similar to their own.  There are some cases in which that assumption would be very charitable indeed.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, February 13, 2020

Morningstar


For years  Morningstar.com was a  good site for investors.  It provided a lot of information on stocks and funds.  Its articles were often interesting and useful. They  were augmented by an easy to use  section for comments by readers who often had their own interesting and useful things to say.  One of the site's best features was that, unlike a competitor such as Marketwatch,  the articles were mainly free of political bias and advocacy.

That has changed. Morningstar has now gone whole hog on evangelizing for the leftist political green religion and beating the drum for so-called ESG  socially and environmentally "aware"  investing.  There is a sermonette on the subject almost every day, and on some days several.  Pages on stocks and funds now contain sections rating them on their degree of ESG-ness with one to five little globes – to mark the planet which must be saved of course  – indicating the score.  There are also “carbon metrics” and a score for “fossil fuel involvement”  to help separate the sinners from the elect. The site no longer allows comments by readers. Perhaps the people in charge got tired of the ridicule and blasphemy they and their faith were getting from the customers.  

It is a little sad to see that happen to something that had been pretty good. However it might be  an opportunity for somebody to create a site like the old Morningstar to give investors useful information and a forum for discussion.  I think there is a market for it.

Labels: , ,

Wednesday, January 15, 2020

Seller's Remorse


It is not surprising  that most people in the  traditional media dislike and oppose Donald Trump. They usually favor leftists and Democrats and work against Republicans.  With  Trump however they have gone far beyond that to a consistent display of hatred for and obsession with the man that can seem hard to explain. Part of the reason for it  may be Trump’s  rude behavior and arrogant  personality. Some of it may be a reaction to his  harsh criticism of them.  However I  think a lot of it could be caused by feelings of remorse or even guilt, because they helped make Trump president.

In 2012 Democrats in Missouri had the problem of reelecting an unpopular United States  senator.  Their solution was to spend around a couple of million dollars running  ads intended to help the weakest  Republican candidate to win the primary election. It worked. Their choice, a man named Todd Akin, got the nomination and, after making some particularly absurd and offensive  statements and being disowned by many people in his own party, was easily beaten in the general election in a state where the Republicans won the election for president. 

In 2016 Democrats and their supporters in the traditional media  had the problem of electing an unpopular and very unlikeable candidate for president. The Republicans had several candidates with good qualifications and political skill and appeal . They also had a man who looked like another Todd Akin, Donald Trump. Walker, Rubio, Cruz and most of the other Republican candidates were more qualified than Trump, but during the primaries Trump was the one who got the most coverage, attention, and boosting in the media.  He eventually  got the nomination, and it seemed that the Republicans were stuck with another Todd Akin, this time in a campaign for the presidency.  However Democrats and their allies in the media underestimated both how unlikeable their candidate was and how many people wanted a change after Obama, and  Trump was elected. Polls showed that he won by doing better than Clinton among voters who liked neither of them.

Media people may not have played Gene Wilder’s role in making the monster, but they probably at least performed Marty Feldman’s. That could be tough for them to live with.

Labels: ,

Sunday, January 12, 2020

Their Business

A person does not have to be a pedant to finds reason to notice some of the lousy ways English is being used in public discourse these days. All he has to do is watch TV or read articles at web sites – including those of large media companies. There is a  lot of bad, awkward, ungrammatical, and sometimes hard to understand stuff coming from people with jobs and  titles that would make a person think they should know better.

One of the worst and most common examples  is  the use of  “their” as singular when the sex  is not specified as  in “an employee is expected to wash their hands  before returning from the restroom”.  (Whose hands would that be, and would the employee have to wait until they showed up in the restroom before going back to work?) There is nothing wrong (though nothing imperative  either) in abandoning the old custom of usually using the masculine term when the sex is indeterminate or where the statement applies to people of both sexes.  There are some acceptable replacements for it.  One can use “he or she” and “his or her”.  One can follow the simple convention of male authors using “he” and “his”  and female authors using “she” and “her”.  One often can finesse things by making everything  plural as with “employees are expected to wash their hands before returning from the restroom”.  Such usages may be awkward at times, but they are better than "their" as singular.

Labels: , ,

Monday, March 18, 2019

A Question for People in the Traditional Media


People in the traditional media tend to emphasize or even sensationalize stories of  extramarital or unconventional sexual activity by conservatives and ignore those about  leftists.  They often try to justify it  by claiming that it is not a result of political bias because what they are focusing on is hypocrisy and not deviations from traditional norms as such.  Since conservatives  are more likely than leftists to claim to adhere traditional Christian doctrine on sex, they are more likely to be fair game for identification and calumny as hypocrites.  

That raises a question. If hypocrisy is what is decisive, why have the same people in the media not reacted similarly to the hypocrisy of leftists including  Sanders, Warren, and many others who preach and moralize endlessly in favor of  equality of wealth and income while amassing fortunes?  One may await an explanation showing how there is no problem of honesty or consistency here.  

Labels: ,

Saturday, February 02, 2019

Progressive Leadership in Virginia


One does not have to be sympathetic when an arrogant, malicious, sanctimonious scoundrel gets a comeuppance, but one should be fair. Racism is the belief that the  members of some races are intrinsically superior or inferior because of their membership in the race. It is not just anything that offends a black politician or some nitwits on social media. Racial prejudice is belief in  judging someone on the basis of his race rather than his individual characteristics and behavior. It is not just  anything that offends a black politician or some nitwits on social media.  Virginia governor Northam’s appearance in a photo in 1984 dressed as either a Ku Kluxer or in blackface as an undignified looking  black man is not proof of either. It could have been only  a  crude and tasteless attempt to be funny. Most of us have tried to be funny in crude or tasteless ways about one thing or another at one time or another, and the 1980s were a far less puritanical and uptight  time than the present.  Northam is a loathsome character even by the standards of his trade, and Virginia would be better off if he were run out of office, but in a sane world he would not be hounded out for this.

Still some of it is  amusing.  There is poetic justice in  is having  a so-called rising star of the Democratic party get taken down for a thirty five year old violation of the canons or political correctness in a yearbook.  It was fine fun  to see those objective,  sharp eyed newshawks at CNN tell their audience that he was a Republican, as was watching other active or potential candidates for the Democrats’ nomination for the presidency in 2020 righteously denounce a possible  rival. It has been a hoot to see him admit he is in the photo and apologize, and then change his mind and deny it when things got really hot.

It also is interesting that the old photo is what caused the commotion among Democrats, rather than his statement seeming to approve of  post-delivery infanticide.  Some people believe abortion is a crime, and some do not, but all civilized people should agree that killing a viable, new born  infant is a crime. That he apparently does not see it that way is a far better reason for pushing him to resign in disgrace than a picture in a yearbook.   That other politicians in his party have not disagreed with him in public on that reveals a lot about them – none of it good.

Labels: , ,

Friday, October 26, 2018

Remember Not to Vote

Not all the foolish statements and wrongheaded thinking during political campaigns come from candidates and their supporters. As the time for an election approaches,  one usually can count on getting pious exhortations from people in the media for everyone  to do his duty and get out and vote.  That is not merely  not right. It is the opposite of right. People who do not think  about political principles or who have not  taken time to learn where the candidates and parties stand on the issues  or who  make their decisions on feelings and emotion have a responsibility not to vote. They should stay home and leave the voting to those among their fellow citizens who know what they are doing. If they have to say anything about it, journalists and talking heads on TV should be urging people to be sure to think and learn before voting, rather than extolling voting itself as a requirement for civic virtue. For people who have not done the thinking and studying to enable them to cast the “informed ballot” are best fulfilling the duties of citizenship by refraining from voting and should be complemented rather than fussed at for doing so

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, February 14, 2018

Communist Governments and the American Media


People make wrong or foolish honest mistakes in judgement all the time. Accepting this fact can go a long way to help one from being drawn  into believing improbable or crazy conspiracy theories. Journalists and broadcasters in the traditional media deserve the same benefits of the doubt as others. However when the same people and organizations do the same things repeatedly and consistently over multiple decades, it is fair to consider that something besides coincidence or honest error is at work.

In the 1930’s while Stalin’s government was murdering millions of  Russians and other residents of the Soviet Union, starving millions of Ukrainians to death in a government created famine, carrying out  bloody purges throughout the country, and  conducting show trials where victims were tortured into confessing to often absurdly improbable or impossible crimes and then murdered, Walter Duranty of the New York Times won a Pulitzer prize for reporting that all was well in the workers’ paradise.  Duranty’s actions were far from unusual.  Whitewashing and even praising  the Soviet tyranny was commonplace among  even mildly leftist writers and journalists of the time.  A  good many agreed with the famous statement  that in seeing the Soviet Union, one had seen the future, and it worked. During  World War II journalists generally ignored both the nature  of the Soviet government and its de facto alliance with Nazi Germany  during the period of the nonaggression pact and presented the Soviets as firm allies of the United States in the struggle of free people against Nazism, when in fact they were more co-belligerents fighting the Nazis for their own reasons (which had nothing to do with anyone’s freedom) and did not participate in joint operations with American  and British forces.

In the immediate postwar years journalists routinely presented Mao and the Chinese Communists as harmless reformers who were to be preferred to the Chinese nationalists and certainly nothing to worry about.  Mao’s  later attacking American forces in Korea and killing and enslaving millions of Chinese did not prevent American journalists from treating him and his little red book as something cool and admirable in the 1960s.  The 1950s saw a media infatuated with Fidel Castro  who was also labeled as a benign reformer, and the sixties gave us the same with Ho Chi Minh. In both of these cases the natures of the regime was misrepresented, and the victims were ignored.  In the 1970s many in the media  promoted various communist or pro-Soviet dictators and governments in Asia, Africa, and Latin America, and ignored or excused their crimes   - including even the atrocities of Pol Pot’s government in Cambodia which some in the press blamed on the United States because of its participation in the war in Vietnam .  During all this time there were continuing efforts to establish a false moral equivalence between the United States and the Soviet Union and to sell the notion that the Soviet empire was prosperous,  successful, well managed, and invincible.

A good percentage of the people in the traditional media either were AWOL or sided at least partially with the Soviets against Reagan in the last phase of the Cold War in the 1980s. It was common to present Reagan as a dangerous warmonger or unrealistic dreamer who did not understand that the Soviets could not be beaten and to give laudatory coverage to advocates for unilateral disarmament  - meaning at that  time advocates for Soviet victory.  When the Cold War was won, Eastern Europe liberated, and the Soviet Empire and the  threat of nuclear war gone,  the line was that Reagan’s policies had nothing to do with it,  that Gorbachev just decided to give up and surrender because he was a nice guy, and the whole thing was not a big deal anyway and certainly nothing to feel “triumphant” about.  

In more recent  times, after a brief and perhaps embarrassed hiatus in the early 1990s, many in the traditional media renewed their affectionate interest in Castro’s government in Cuba and found much to admire and excuse in Chavez’s government in Venezuela and other leftist despotisms around the world.  This sort of  thing along with a revisionism on  and willful forgetting of the failures and crimes of communism in the 20th Century continued throughout the Bush and Obama years.  Now in the last few days we have seen people from CNN, the New York Times and other outfits fawning over a representative of North Korea’s monstrous communist dictatorship.

There may not be a conspiracy  here, but there clearly is a pattern, one of a fondness or soft spot for communist ideas and tyrannies.   It happens too consistently to dismiss as accidental without considering that it might be something else.  

Labels: , ,

Thursday, January 25, 2018

A Friend's Advice on Reading History


A friend of mine who enjoys reading history told me he tries to stick to books written before the 1960’s because he finds recent books to be inferior and less likely to be truthful.  That is a little too strong. There were bad, inaccurate, sloppy,  biased, and worthless books on history written in the old days, and there have been some good ones written lately, but my friend does have a point. The game often is being played differently  these days at least by academic historians. A lot of what has come out in the last fifty years is corrupted by leftist propaganda, multiculturalist special pleading, and a general post-modernist abandonment of objectivity, proportion, and intellectual honesty. Caveat lector is certainly good advice.    

The same thing is true for popular reference works, including  Wikipedia.  While it can be fine source on non-controversial  topics in fields such as mathematics and the physical sciences, Wikipedia often  is unreliable on topics with political content or relevance –including history.  The propaganda, special pleading, and lack of objectivity, proportion, and intellectual honesty mentioned above can show up  both in the articles and the selection of cited references. An old encyclopedia such as a Britannica from the mid-20th Century sometimes will serve a curious reader better. Besides it never hurts to check more than one source even in casual reading or completing assignments for school. 

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, December 05, 2017

Hollywood, TV, and Business

Many people have noticed and complained that business people are usually depicted in American movies and TV shows (including news shows) as villains.  The usual explanation is that  the industry is controlled by leftists whose work displays their ideology.  While that is well supported by evidence, I think there may be another important reason for the bias. 

When one sees  a priest or preacher denounce all humanity as inherently base, wicked, and damnable, it is fair and useful to remember that the human being he knows best is himself.  When one sees a white American leftist denounce white Americans as vile, pampered, exploitive,  racial bigots who do not deserve anything they have, it is fair and useful to remember that the white American he knows best is himself.  Similarly when one sees people in the movie and TV business  depict  business people as vicious, scheming, unprincipled, hypocritical, brutal phonies and scoundrels, it is fair and useful to remember the business they know best is their own.


While the opinions of business they present are false about  the business world in general,  they  could be accurate and justified takes on business as practiced in  the  industry in which  they live and work  - one dominated by its Kevin Spaceys, Harvey Weinsteins, and Matt Lauers.  There they have direct experience and might know what they are talking about. 

Labels: , , , ,

Thursday, August 31, 2017

Hurricane Harvey Notes

We made a donation today to relief for victims of Hurricane Harvey. We picked the Samaritan’s Purse organization, but there are various good choices out there such as the Red Cross. I hope many people will make donations.   I would suggest avoiding any organization controlled by Sylvester Turner or any other politicians or officials in Houston’s city government for the obvious reasons that hack  politicians usually cannot be trusted with money in amounts larger than thirty cents.

As was predictable some have tried to find political advantage in the disaster.  Devotees of the green religion in the media and politics have painted the hurricane as a dire result of global warming, ignoring the both the fact that hurricanes have occurred  in the Atlantic and the Gulf of Mexico as long has people have kept records and the fact that there has been recent lull in hurricanes hitting the US.  One leftist cartoonist managed to ridicule Christians, Texans, libertarians, and conservatives all at once with a vulgar cartoon of a buffoonish Texan with a “secede” placard  being rescued from a flood and attributing his good fortune to divine providence when it is actually due to his omni-benevolent (except for Trump) federal government.  After being criticized the cartoonist waffled and claimed he was really only wanting to insult secessionists and not Texans in general. Well, one can wait and see if he produces something similar featuring a Calexit favoring leftist the next time that state has a natural disaster. That’s probably not the way to bet.

Of course conservatives made their political points as well. One on the radio, noting the large number of black people getting rescued, wondered why the Black Lives Matter crowd was nowhere to be seen in a situation where others of all races were pitching in to help their fellow Americans and suggested that actual black lives in themselves may not matter too much to BLM. It was a rude observation but not an unreasonable one.  


The dumbest comments came from some in the traditional media who, while not disputing  the substantive  things the administration is doing, fretted that Trump was not emotional and schmaltzy enough and did not deliver a sufficient amount of made-for-TV  “empathy”.  I don’t know for sure, but I would guess that most victims would prefer ten cents of actual assistance to fifty bucks worth of a politician's empathy any day. In their position, I certainly would. 

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, August 03, 2017

Admission to Colleges

This week at the White House a reporter asked the press secretary if people in the administration thought affirmative action policies at colleges discriminated against white students in a manner suggesting holding such an opinion would be at least a hideous breach of etiquette and probably something far worse.  (The question was probably inspired by  information leaked  to the New York Times about  Department of Justice hiring lawyers to look into the question of discrimination in admissions to colleges and by the reactions to it of  various Democratic politicians and their friends.  It turned out that the investigation apparently will deal with claims of discrimination against Asian students. The Times missed that, whether carelessly or perhaps on the premise that its audience would appreciate the evil of the thing more readily if the possible beneficiaries were white.)

The accepted  hypocrisies and taboos  of a society require that certain things not be publicly mentioned or considered even if they are not only  true but  obviously so.  Affirmative action in college admissions is a good example. Admission policies  which set lower standards   for black and Hispanic applicants than for white and Asian ones discriminate against the latter two. By excluding them from admission, these policies harm all white and Asian applicants  whose qualifications are below the white/Asian acceptance point(s)  but above the black/Hispanic one(s).   It is possible to argue honestly (though I think wrongly) that such discrimination is a good thing, but it is not possible to argue honestly that the discrimination does not exist.  If person A has higher overall qualifications for admission  than person B before  the race of either is considered  but is rejected while B is accepted once  the race of each is considered, then A has been discriminated against on the basis of race.


The dust up this week illustrates how well accepted the hypocrisy and taboo on this issue are. It also indicates more than a little fear among those who favor something they may not be able to defend. 

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, June 29, 2017

Trump and the Press

The feud between Trump and his people and members of the traditional media is amusing to watch, at least for people who both have strong stomachs and enjoy a good farce.  There is certainly something comical in watching people  for whose attitude and  behavior  toward Obama the terms “cheerleader” and  “lickspittle”  were often too mild suddenly discovering  the sacred duty of the press in this  great republic to take an adversarial and skeptical approach to those in power.  It is fine low humor when they disclaim any political or ideological motives or biases and profess, usually with fairly straight faces, a disinterested commitment  to give us just the facts ma’am.  It gets lower and broader when they whine about being picked on and misunderstood and not getting their due respect as arbiters of what is good and true.  Then  we have Trump tweeting and blustering  in ways beneath the dignity of the presidency of either the United States or the Delta house at Faber College.   (This does not mean Trump is wrong about the malice, dishonesty, and bias. He’s not, but he surely could deal with the situation in less strange ways.) There is entertainment there too. 

Many  people take this dust up  seriously, but I see no reason  to do so.  Some of Trump’s supporters  worry that this is a slow moving coup d’etat, and that the Democrats and their servants in the press will be able to depose Trump as they  brought down Nixon.  This seems unlikely for several reasons. Nixon handled  the business over Watergate in ways which gave his enemies something  to work with.  Despite months of effort  Trump’s enemies have found nothing comparable to attach to him.  The Democrats controlled both houses of Congress  and had almost  all the important media organizations with them when they went after Nixon.  This time the Democrats are in the minority in both houses, and there are important nontraditional media people and organizations who are not working with them and often opposing them. So it seems very unlikely  that Trump will be run out of office or even be harmed much at all.

Some of Trump’s opponents  fret that the spats between Trump and  his enemies in the traditional media are a threat to freedom of the press or even a danger to constitutional government.  This seems almost paranoid if sincere.  There is no evidence of Trump or his people attempting to harm, threaten, or silence anyone in the media.  (They have not, for example,  put a reporter from a network they didn’t like under criminal investigation as Obama’s  people did.)  They are just criticizing their critics, often rudely, and pointing out their bias.  Criticism in response  is what one should expect when one makes continual public attacks on a president not named Bush.  Obama and his people  had no reluctance about  saying what they thought of Limbaugh and various others on TV or radio, and few if any in the traditional media complained that that might be a threat to the First Amendment.  Unless things change there seems to be no reason in this stuff to be concerned about freedom of the press.


The questions and issues  of policies in the government and  honesty and trustworthiness in the media are important.  The feud  is a sideshow, and at times a fairly funny one.  

Labels: , ,

Saturday, January 21, 2017

Reactions to "America First"

Several in the traditional media have decried Trump’s use of the phrase “America first”, tying it to the America First Committee which opposed America’s entering World War II in the months before Pearl Harbor and even claiming  that through such a connection Trump is being anti-Semitic and “dark”. There are several things wrong with this  - the most  obvious being the fact that there is no evidence Trump cares about or  intended to associate himself with that anti-war group of over seventy five years ago.

Beyond that there is some convenient forgetfulness on the left about political situations and activities in this country in the time between September 1939 and December 1941. President Roosevelt’s efforts to support Britain and prepare this country for the trouble ahead faced opposition from a variety of sources.  The noninterventionists were a politically diverse bunch.  Norman Thomas, the leader and frequent presidential candidate of the Socialist Party, was both an anti-interventionist and a friendly associate of members of the America First Committee as were other prominent people who were far from conservatives.   During the period of the nonaggression pact when the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany were de facto allies, American communists and their fellow travelers mainly followed Stalin’s directions and opposed intervention in what they called Britain’s imperialistic war.  (This changed overnight after June 22, 1941 when  the party line became one of demanding action against Stalin’s new enemy.) 

I would guess the  real objections are less to Trump's use of the slogan than to the notion behind it of a foreign policy based on this country’s national security interests. Many on the left have a fairly automatic hostility to actions advancing those interests and often to the interests themselves. 

I don’t know what Trump’s policy of  “America first” will  mean in practice. I expect there will be things to support and things to oppose.Much of what he as said about trade is just wrong.  We’ll have to wait and see. However I  have no  objection to the notion in principle.  No one expects the foreign policies of the  governments of France, Germany, Britain, or any other foreign country to fail to put their national security interests first.  Our government should do the same and especially should avoid wars and military interventions in places and situations in the Middle East where those interests are not threatened.


Labels: , , ,

Thursday, September 01, 2016

Kaepernick in the News

A few days ago Colin Kaepernick, a benched quarterback for a mediocre team in the NFL, made big news by denouncing the United States as oppressive to  minorities and by refusing to stand during the playing of the national anthem at the beginning of a football game.  Since then the news has been full of articles and commentaries defending or denouncing him. While I found nothing worth noticing about either Kaepernick or what he might say about  this or any other topic, I did find something  a little interesting in  some  of the reactions.  


The most amusing thing to me was the phony basis for the  praise he got for being brave, daring, and controversial. In  fact he took no risk at all with anyone who matters, because his actions fell within the boundaries of what is acceptable by the rules  of political correctness.  The officials of the NFL whose usual demands for total uniformity have had them in  tizzies over  such things as slightly deflated footballs,  someone wanting to wear  high  top football shoes to honor a deceased player, and stickers honoring dead cops,  said this  was just fine.  The officials of his team did the same. Many in the establishment media were effusive in supporting  him, and many others were at least appreciative of his “message”, if not his methods.   What he did seems no more brave or daring  than speaking out in favor of dolphins or puppies.  (Now if he had, for example, waved a little rebel battle flag while running onto the field and rhapsodized to reporters about the Lost Cause, that actually would have been bold, risky, and controversial, albeit bizarre.  It would also have gotten him fired, exiled from the league,  and left without support or sympathy  in the media.) It may even have saved him from being cut from the team for incompetence, since his bosses  may now be afraid to let him go.  

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, February 20, 2016

Manning and the Media

The recent flap in the sports media over Peyton Manning is worth noticing. The story itself is trivial and insignificant. Depending on whom one believes,  about twenty years ago Manning as a young college player either mooned a teammate while a female trainer was working on his ankle, giving her an unintended but unwelcome view of his testicles and backside, or flashed her with that view intentionally.  As might have been expected in those post- Anita Hill and pre-Monica Lewinsky days, there was a series of  accusations, legal actions, and settlements which went on for a good while.  There was no hint in any version of the story of sexual assault, groping or striking the woman,  or anything beyond puerile and  moronic horseplay of a sort not too unusual in teenage boys.  The story was old news and had been so for over a decade until several sportswriters and commentators revived it after the Super Bowl.

Now, all of a sudden, we are getting a campaign of shocked and sanctimonious denunciations of Manning and pompous ruminations about whether or to what degree this destroys his “legacy” or even proves he is a phony and an evil person. That is odd enough that it’s useful to try to figure out why.

The first thing one might notice is that the offense, even Manning’s version of it, violates the canons of political correctness as they apply to gender. Here was a woman working in the locker room with a bunch of youthful jocks.  One of them behaved like a youthful jock in a locker room, instead of realizing that women are  strong, tough as nails,  and able to function in any environment  or situation and simultaneously  delicate Victorian flowers who will be horribly damaged by any sort of unseemly conduct or language, and then conducting himself accordingly.  The horror is there for all to see.

The next  thing which comes to mind is that Manning is white, and for many in the media there are different standards  for white and black athletes. Violent run ins with cops and ordinary citizens, profligate fathering of illegitimate children, beating up women (so long as no pictures or videos hit the news), and rap sheets  of assorted felonies are accepted as  normal and unremarkable and either unmentioned or quickly dismissed or forgiven if the athlete is black. White guys generally are more likely to be  expected to behave themselves and to be given nothing like this sort of slack when they do not  - even in comparatively minor ways.   (While on the surface this might appear to be sensitive to and solicitous of black people, in fact it shows a clear prejudice against them, since the indicated  conclusion is that the people doing this  do not think blacks are  worthy of being held to and capable of meeting usual behavioral standards.  In that assumption  they  find themselves in agreement with a common opinion of anti-black bigots and racists.)

Politics may also be part of it. Manning is a Republican and  young, attractive, popular, articulate, competitive, and in need of something to do with the rest of his life. Most of the people in the media are on the left, and there could have been a desire to torpedo a possible political career in the wrong party.  Then there are the simple explanations of envy, resentment, and schadenfreude which always should be considered in such cases.


This is all  just guess work, the product of lazy speculation on a warm Saturday afternoon, but the scope and intensity of the thing  are  strange.  

Labels: , , , ,