Monday, October 12, 2026

Sprague De Camp Nonfiction

 

L. Sprague de Camp is mainly known as a writer of fiction – especially science fiction and fantasy. Much of it is still in print, and more can be found in used bookstores on on Ebay. I have found that he also wrote some interesting and worthwhile nonfiction, sometimes in collaboration with his wife Catherine.


Lost Continents is a history of the Atlantis and related myths from the time of Plato to the 1950s, a survey of literature on the subject, and an amusing treatment of various crackpots and their theories of lost continents and of various cultists who included tales of lost continents in their doctrines. It covers its subjects thoroughly.


The Heroic Age of American Invention is a history of American inventors and inventions in the 19th Century. De Camp was an expert on patents and patent law, and there is a little too much inside baseball on patent fights and litigation, but the stories are fascinating and informative.


The title of The Ancient Engineers is misleading. The book actually covers remarkable feats of engineering and design in various cultures from the building of the pyramids to the Renaissance.


Citadels of Mystery has another fairly misleading title. In considering several remarkable structures built in places around the world in pre-industrial times, it refutes a number of fantastic theories and clears up some mysteries about their origins. It treats the cultures that built them fairly and objectively, rejecting spurious 19th Century racial theories while also avoiding sappy romanticizing of the sort popular in our time.


De Camp was a fair and thoughtful historian here, and a good writer. That is a fine combination, and these four books are worth reading.


Labels: ,

Saturday, February 07, 2026

Stolen Lands Again

 

Leftists are fond of claiming that all of America is “stolen land” taken from the Indians and making “acknowledgments” about it. Conservatives observe correctly that this has not led to leftists handing things they own over to any Indians, and the charge of hypocrisy is accurate. However it misses the most important point. It is possible for hypocrites to be right in principle about something on which they are hypocritical. It is necessary to refute the claims, not just show the leftists are being phonies.


The notion of theft presupposes the notion of property. If there were no property, that is things that rightly belong to someone, there could be no theft. People acquire property rights to land in a wilderness by settling it – by building permanent dwellings such as a town or village on it or by farming , ranching, mining, or otherwise developing it. Moving through land on nomadic hunting trips, having a small village within miles of it, or marching across it in the name of the King of Spain does not acquire property rights to it. Some of the land in what is now the United States was fully settled by Indians, and any newcomers should have respected their property, and, if they wanted it, bought it from them (which often happened as when the Dutch bought Manhattan). Those who did otherwise were wrong. However most of the continent north of the Rio Grande was wilderness belonging to no one. It was not stolen and could not have been stolen.


It is interesting that the proponents of the idea of America as stolen lands seem mainly to be socialists and communists who generally deny the whole idea of property rights, showing that if one hates America enough, any excuse will do, and any inconsistency is acceptable. Some others are rich, posturing phonies who deserve to be called on their phoniness. It would be amusing to see what the defense would be if some Vermont Indians showed up in court demanding ownership of, say, a famous ice cream factory in the state, or some California Indians laid claim to a well known singer’s mansion. That would be worth paying to watch.

Labels: , ,

Friday, February 10, 2023

Lies and History

 

For years before and into the 1960s, there was a version of American history popular in the south and often accepted elsewhere claiming that the Confederates did not rebel in defense of slavery but over some other concerns, that slaves were well treated by their kind and genteel owners, and that slaves were satisfied with their condition. Every one of these assertions is false. These days very few people believe otherwise, and most would agree the history of slavery, the Civil War, reconstruction, and Jim Crow should be understood and taught accurately without such fables.


However we now have a new set of fables in place of the old, one claiming that Lincoln and the union army did not free the slaves who rather did it themselves spontaneously or something, that America and its wealth were built on slavery, that the American revolution was fought to escape from British abolitionists, and that ubiquitous, systemic white racism has resulted in a de facto continuation of Jim Crow into the present. Every one of these assertions is false. Yet they are preached in universities, diversity reeducation sessions, public schools, media companies, and even, for gosh sakes, Disney cartoons.


In accuracy and intent they are on the level of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion and should get the same dismissal and contempt. There is no justification for accepting dishonest cover stories that all that is really wanted is to get the full story told. It has nothing to do with that. It is lying to libel this country and an entire race of people.


Labels: , ,

Monday, May 09, 2022

V-E Day

 

Yesterday was V-E day. It has been seventy seven years since the allied victory ending World War II in Europe. V-E and V-J day are now farther in the past than Lee’s surrender to Grant at Appomattox was on the day Pearl Harbor was attacked. It took millions of Americans to win that war. Few of them are left, and soon all will be gone. My father and one of his brothers served in the Pacific. Another brother served stateside. Two of my mother’s brothers served in Europe. At least two uncles by marriage also served. They and all the rest need to be remembered. They saved civilization.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, August 05, 2020

Truman and Hiroshima

Tomorrow is the 75th anniversary  of the dropping of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima. There likely will be more than the usual amount of superficial second guessing and pious anti-American hand wringing in the traditional media.

 There are also serious second guessers – historians and military officers who wonder whether Truman made the right decision. I think he did, and that the bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki was the least costly way to end the war, not only for Americans but also for the Japanese. In the summer of 1945 there were still millions of men and thousands of airplanes available to the Japanese to defend the home islands from invasion and determination to use them. I have read that Japanese officers estimated that an invasion could be stopped at a cost of ten million dead Japanese soldiers and civilians. After the slaughter on Iwo Jima and on and in the waters around Okinawa,  American officers projected numbers of American casualties in an invasion ranging from several hundred thousand to a million.  In addition to that the Japanese are said to have planned  to murder the thousands of allied prisoners of war in camps around the Pacific when their homeland was invaded.  While one cannot be sure that there was not something other than dropping the atomic bombs which might have led the Japanese to surrender without being invaded, it is interesting to note that after the atomic bombs fell and the Japanese decided to surrender, there was an attempted coup in Tokyo to cancel the surrender and continue the war.  

My father was a Republican, but Harry Truman was a  Democrat he always thought well of.  He was a crew member on transport planes in World War II. He told me that in 1945 his unit was stationed in Hawaii and was scheduled to drop paratroopers during the invasion of Japan.  It was expected that during the invasion the Japanese would try to stop incoming allied planes by crashing kamikaze planes flown by inexperienced pilots into them as they reached Japan. So I  along with a great many other boomers have a personal interest in Truman’s decision to use the bomb. Without it a lot of us might never have been here at all.


Labels: , ,

Monday, December 03, 2018

George H. W. Bush


George H. W. Bush served honorably  in World War II, had plenty of physical courage, stayed married to the same women for his entire adult life, raised a family with her, and did well in business.  Based on what is publicly known, he seems to have led a decent, respectable,  and successful private life in which there was much to admire.

He also had a career of over a quarter of a century as a politician and bureaucrat.  He came from a wealthy and influential New England family and was a typical example of what was once called a Rockefeller Republican.   There are reasons one of his obituaries used the term “patrician”.  (As with most politicians he tried to put on a man-of-the-people act, but his seemed especially  weak, pork rinds or no.)

He ran for the senate from Texas in 1964 and lost but was elected to the house in 1966.  After leaving the house and losing another race for the senate in 1970,  he had several appointed jobs in government including director of the CIA. Ronald Reagan selected him as his running mate in 1980 – perhaps to placate the Republican establishment - despite their many disagreements and a rough campaign for the nomination in which Bush called Reagan’s economic ideas voodoo.  After eight years as vice president, Bush was elected president in 1988, mainly on the basis of Reagan’s successes and as someone under whom the government would continue in the same  direction.  Some called it an election for Reagan’s third term. It turned out to be nothing of the sort.  Bush double-crossed his benefactor, announcing that his would be a kinder, gentler government than that of his presumably unkind and ungentle predecessor, ended  the Reagan revolution, and governed  as a big government Republican. Reagan had made a serious mistake in  failing to endorse as his successor someone who shared his ideas and would continue his work.   Bush  double-crossed his voters by reneging  on his emphatic promise to oppose increases in taxes.  He frittered away both the political capital he inherited from Reagan and his own from a successful war over Kuwait and lost the presidency in 1992 in a three way race where enough usually Republican voters abandoned him for a strange but seemingly sincere amateur to give the presidency  to a little known southern Democrat with a shady background.   

Bush had a well known disdain for ideology and what he contemptuously called the vision thing. This was his worst failing.  An ideology is just  a set of political principles. ( When he made obligatory statements about principles, his insincerity and discomfort struck people as obvious. He seems to have been a person to whom such things are not seriously or operationally important.)  Without one  it is hard for a politician to have moral courage,  steadfastness, or reasoned convictions or to do much good.  That showed with him. He was the wrong person for the job in 1988, and the country suffered for it.


Labels: , ,

Sunday, November 11, 2018

A Hundred Years Later


The history of governments in most of the world for most of the time has been one of  various levels of barbarism.  In Europe  Greece during its greatest days condoned slavery and subjugation by conquest. The Roman empire was largely based on those things. The Christian middle ages were a model for later totalitarianism.  The politics of the Renaissance were brutal and bloody, and the religious wars following the Reformation were awful. English authorities were still torturing and murdering English men and women for their religious opinions in the Sixteenth Century, and the Scottish government hanged a man for blasphemy in 1697.  The rulers of France were breaking men on the wheel in the mid-1700s.  Governments in Spain, Russia, and much of the rest of the continent were worse as were those in Africa and Asia.  The reason we have the term “oriental despot” is the throughout history most of the populated areas of North Africa and in  Asia from Anatolia to the Pacific have  been governed despotically.  The Inca and Aztec empires  were rigid autocracies  (with the Aztecs adding in gruesome mass human sacrifice of prisoners), and the Spanish and Portuguese conquerors who replaced them ruled as brutal tyrants.  In North America the English colony of Massachusetts put women on trial as witches as late as 1692, and the trade in slaves continued for over a century after that.

From the 1600s on thinkers in western Europe devised new theories of the proper nature of government and argued for the liberal values of individual rights, freedom of conscience and expression, liberty, and limitations on the powers of  the state. By the end of the 19th Century these ideas had led to the abolition of slavery and serfdom, a general toleration of dissenting religious opinions, and limitations (varying in degree from place to place) on the powers of authorities throughout the parts of the world governed by Europeans or descendants of Europeans.   There was a fairly generally held belief in a progressive evolution toward better societies, not out of naivete but because people had been  observing it happen.

Things changed with the tragedy of the First World War.  The war made a reversion toward barbarism possible,  and in its aftermath in  Russia, Germany, Spain, Italy, and some of the  states created from parts of the old Austrian empire barbarism arrived.  The Second World War following from the First got rid of the Nazis but otherwise made the spread of barbarism more likely. Communist tyrannies took control in China and Soviet-dominated areas of eastern and central Europe. The postwar demise of the British and French  empires led to the creation of  locally controlled governments in Asia and Africa which were almost uniformly worse than the colonial administrations they replaced and often horribly  worse. 

The defeat of the Soviet Union in the cold war and the collapse of the Soviet empire caused  many people to believe at the time of the millennium that the regressions of the 20th Century were  an aberration, and that evolution toward a more liberal world would resume. For many that hope has faded. Now pessimists in this country fear a coming  end of the United States as a liberal republic will make a general triumph of barbarism inevitable.

I see  their point  but don’t accept their conclusion. There are both time and opportunity for America and the world to produce a better outcome.  Still a person being realistic has  to admit that in many ways  the great war that ended a hundred years ago today put civilization behind a good sized eight ball. The tragedy did not end on 11/11/1918.

Labels: , ,

Thursday, January 25, 2018

A Friend's Advice on Reading History


A friend of mine who enjoys reading history told me he tries to stick to books written before the 1960’s because he finds recent books to be inferior and less likely to be truthful.  That is a little too strong. There were bad, inaccurate, sloppy,  biased, and worthless books on history written in the old days, and there have been some good ones written lately, but my friend does have a point. The game often is being played differently  these days at least by academic historians. A lot of what has come out in the last fifty years is corrupted by leftist propaganda, multiculturalist special pleading, and a general post-modernist abandonment of objectivity, proportion, and intellectual honesty. Caveat lector is certainly good advice.    

The same thing is true for popular reference works, including  Wikipedia.  While it can be fine source on non-controversial  topics in fields such as mathematics and the physical sciences, Wikipedia often  is unreliable on topics with political content or relevance –including history.  The propaganda, special pleading, and lack of objectivity, proportion, and intellectual honesty mentioned above can show up  both in the articles and the selection of cited references. An old encyclopedia such as a Britannica from the mid-20th Century sometimes will serve a curious reader better. Besides it never hurts to check more than one source even in casual reading or completing assignments for school. 

Labels: , ,

Tuesday, October 03, 2017

Reparations

The principle that a person should never accept undeserved guilt is immensely important.   We should accept responsibility (and blame or guilt if appropriate) for our actual failures and wrongdoing, but for nothing more.  Inducing  undeserved feelings of guilt in people  is one the most effective and commonly attempted ways to gain control over them.  Religions, governments, social movements, and other power seekers have used and still use it successfully. Guilt ridden people usually are easier led and dominated than  the self-confident.

Some leftists have attempted to blame all (or at least all non-leftist) white Americans for slavery and Jim Crow. These claims are invalid. There is no American alive who owned a slave, saw anyone held as a slave, or did anything to further or tolerate the institution of slavery in this country, and so no one alive is to blame.   Jim Crow segregation laws were repealed in 1964.  The last election electing the (Democratic Party) politicians who supported and perpetuated Jim Crow was in 1962.  The voting age then was twenty one.  So no one born after 1941 could have contributed even by voting to the continuation of Jim Crow, much less by holding political office. White  Americans born after that time and white Americans of any age who never supported the segregationists are  not responsible for  the wrongs of the Jim Crow laws and should reject any claims that they are.   

Leftists have also floated the idea of seizing wealth from white Americans and giving it to black Americans as reparations for slavery.  Forced reparations can be justified only as punishment for crimes or as a means of restitution.  The people who committed the crimes of slavery are long dead. Present day white people had nothing to do with it and should resist and reject any attempt to blame or punish them for crimes they did not commit, just as rational and liberally minded people should reject other notions of vicarious guilt, original sin, or moral taint from the sins of ancestors. 

That leaves restitution. Restitution is the returning  by a criminal to his victim of the property stolen from him.  Restitution from a  criminal to his victim is always appropriate.  Restitution from an  innocent heir of a criminal to a victim or an heir of a victim can be appropriate but only if an identifiable  amount of stolen property or gain from disposing  the stolen property exists to be returned.  For example  if person A’s mother cheated person B’s father out of thirty acres of land in 1996, and the fraud can be proved, and person A still holds the property as her mother’s heir, B might have a valid  claim to it.  However if one of A’s remote ancestors cheated one of B’s out of a tenth interest in a whaling vessel  in Boston in 1694, it probably would be impossible for  B to have a claim on A that could be justified or quantified.  The ship would be long gone, and multiple events in the intervening three hundred years would have influenced the present conditions of both A and B  (and numerous other descendants of the crook and the victim) to a point where nothing A had could be identified  as stolen property.  In the case of slavery it would almost always be impossible to attribute anything held by a particular  present day white person to the labor stolen by an ancestor of his from an ancestor of a particular black person, and so restitution would not be applicable.  The exceptions would be very and probably vanishingly infrequent. 

Any widespread payment of reparations  to black people of today from white Americans for slavery  is both very unlikely and incapable of justification. The notion  is no more sound  than demands for reparations  to present day Englishmen from Italians for the Roman occupation and enslavement of Britannia would be.  It is a reasonable  guess that at least some  of those floating the idea know this and are cynically bringing it up  to increase   feelings of resentment in some people  and of  guilt in others for political reasons.


Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, July 05, 2017

Statues of Confederates

“I felt like anything rather than rejoicing at the downfall of a foe who had fought so long and valiantly, and had suffered so much for a cause, though that cause was, I believe, one of the worst for which a people ever fought, and one for which there was the least excuse.”
- Memoirs of Ulysses. S. Grant, describing his feelings at Appomattox

In the last few years governments in several cities have removed or hidden statues honoring confederate soldiers.   In some places schools and streets which were named for rebels have been renamed.  Some people applaud this as appropriate while others see it as an example of dogmatic  political correctness, a denial of historical fact, or even a desecration of their heritage. 

Before deciding whether it was proper to honor people such as Robert E. Lee, Stonewall Jackson, or Jeb Stuart,  one has to know what  they were being honored for. Lee was an admirable man  and a skilled, formidable,  valiant, and determined commander.   So were some other confederate officers.  Many ordinary confederate soldiers fought bravely and gallantly,  often in very  trying or even desperate conditions.   It is entirely appropriate to respect and admire them for these qualities and deeds.  However these men committed treason against the United States, and the cause they fought for was not merely wrong but despicable.  

To  me the most relevant question on the statues and monuments is  whether they  were intended and serve only or mainly to commemorate historical events and/or honor confederate soldiers  for what they did in the war or more as acts of  defiance and to promote their indefensible lost cause.   The monuments I’ve seen at places such as  Shiloh and Gettysburg  are usually the former and should be left alone, while many of those in city  parks and squares probably were done as the latter.  While I see no necessity for removing them, neither do I see anything wrong with doing so.  I’d certainly rather have statues of Grant or Sherman or Sheridan or others who were on the right side.


Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, April 20, 2016

Twenty Dollar Bill

It is often interesting and informative when people descend into unintentional self-parody. A good recent example is the government’s decision to replace Andrew Jackson on the twenty dollar bill with Harriet Tubman. The essence of affirmative action is the act of rewarding individuals from favored groups solely on the basis of their membership in those groups and equating their modest abilities and accomplishments to the greater abilities and accomplishments of individuals not in the groups. (People of real ability and accomplishment from favored groups do not need affirmative action and are often unfairly tarred by assumptions that they owe their success to it.)

Tubman was one of many brave people who worked with the underground railroad to rescue slaves in the south and transport them to safety in the north. That is commendable, but she was only one of many and, in fact, did far less to end slavery than her contemporary who shared her first name Harriet Beecher Stowe.

Now consider the other people pictured on American currency.  George Washington was literally the father of the nation. He commanded American forces during the revolution, chaired the convention which created the constitution, declined an opportunity to become king, and as the first president set  the nation firmly on course as a constitutional republic.

Thomas Jefferson wrote  the Declaration of Independence, worked for a bill of rights in the constitution, supported laws protecting religious freedom, attempted to end slavery, was an important inventor, scientist, author, and architect, and secured the nation and doubled its size by making the Louisiana Purchase.

Abraham Lincoln saved the Union, guided the nation to victory in the Civil War, and ended slavery.

Alexander Hamilton was a leader of the revolution and a skilled administrator who is credited with putting the new American government’s finances on sound footing and preventing it from financial collapse.

Ulysses S. Grant as a military commander won the Civil War for the Union army by first defeating the Confederacy in the west and then overcoming the formerly unbeatable army of Robert E. Lee in the east. Later as president his was the only administration for almost a hundred years to try to protect the rights of black Americans in the south.

Benjamin Franklin was perhaps the most famous scientist of the late 18th Century, an accomplished author, a talented inventor, a successful diplomat and  a leader of the revolution and a founder of the nation.

Equating Tubman to these men in historical importance is  an example of affirmative action in action  which easily reaches the level of self-parody.

None of this is intended to defend Andrew Jackson. He is a mixed figure. He did some very good things such as defeating the British at New Orleans. He also did some very bad things such as creating the modern Democratic party.


Labels: , ,

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Webb's Texas Rangers

Recently I finally read Walter Prescott Webb’s history of the Texas Rangers, something I had been planning to do for a good while. It is a fine and comprehensive history covering the rangers from their beginnings in the Texas Revolution to their activities in the 1930’s, depicting   both their legendary accomplishments and successes and  their failures and misdeeds.  The rangers as variously organized served in the revolution, the Mexican War, the struggles with the Comanches from the 1830’s through the 1870’s, the later fights with Apaches in West Texas, a century of trouble along the Rio Grande, and as lawmen fighting  the murderers, feudists,  horse and cattle thieves, and other criminals both on the frontier and in the state’s settle areas.

The book does an excellent job of making plain just how wild much of Texas was in much of the time it covers.  When the rangers began their work, the western edge  of civilization in Texas ran roughly from Corpus Christi to San Antonio to the Red River north of Dallas.  With the exception of a few Spanish settlements near the Rio Grande, the rest of the state was wild, mainly unpopulated, lawless, and  very dangerous.  Bands of Comanche, Apache, and other plains and desert Indians fought  each other and raided the Mexican settlements and ranches along and south of the Rio Grande and the Texans along the frontier. In the two decades after the Civil War much of the western half of the state was settled   by ranchers and others, though  some of the areas along the Mexican border upstream of Laredo and in the Trans-Pecos region in far west Texas remained wild until at least the time of  the first world war.  The book closes in the 1930’s on an almost completely settled and civilized state where a good deal of the credit for that accomplishment belonged to the rangers. 

Though the author obviously respects and admires his subjects, the book is generally fair in its treatment of the various participants in its story. (There is one main exception. The author, who published the book in 1935, shows the  low opinion of reconstruction and the coalition of blacks, Republicans, and federal troops who controlled the state during that era typical of a southern Democrat of his time. That bias comes through at times in his treatment of the period and of federal soldiers, particularly black ones.) Refreshingly for a reader these days, it is also completely devoid of political correctness with the author pulling no punches about the cruelty and duplicity of Mexican bandits and officials or the savagery of the plains Indians. He simply relates what actually happened in a manner free of the agendas,  special pleading, and   affirmative action with regard to content which afflict so much present day writing in history.  


In addition to presenting a the story of the rangers, the book does a fine job of setting and explaining the varying contexts they operated in  the hundred years from the revolution to the 1930’s. I recommend it highly. 

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, June 04, 2014

Midway 2014

In June of 1942 outnumbered and outgunned American forces of the Pacific Fleet engaged the Japanese Navy in the world’s most important and decisive naval battle since Trafalgar, a battle which determined  that World War II in  the Pacific would end with a Japanese defeat.  The American task forces’ three aircraft carriers, including the recently patched up Yorktown which had been made battle ready in an astoundingly short time after suffering damage in an earlier battle, faced a Japanese force of four large and two small carriers.  The balance in surface firepower was even more in favor of the Japanese, as the Americans went to sea with no battleships and fewer cruisers and destroyers than their enemy.  The main battle was fought on June 4, 1942 though some action continued for a couple of days later. It ended with all four of the large Japanese carriers sunk and most of their pilots and planes lost, with the Japanese abandoning their plans to occupy Midway Island, and with the United States losing only one of its carriers, the Yorktown. It was both one of the most complete victories in military history and perhaps the quickest reversal in the strategic positions of two adversaries in world history.  

After Midway the Japanese, who has swept through Asia and the Pacific in the six months after Pearl Harbor, conquering Malaysia, Burma, Hong Kong, Singapore, what is now Indonesia, the Philippines, and half of New Guinea, and occupying numerous islands in the Pacific including Guam and two in the Aleutian Islands of Alaska, never went on the offensive against the United States again.  Instead, just two months after the battle, the United States began its first major offensive of the war at Guadalcanal in the Solomon Islands and remained on the offensive until the defeat of Japan in 1945.
 
If the victory had gone to the Japanese, they would have been able to remain on the offensive, probably severing  the line of bases in the South Pacific connecting America to Australia and New Zealand  and perhaps even threatening American control of the Hawaiian Islands.  There would have been no opportunity for American offensives until at least well into 1943, and the Japanese would have had much additional time  to strengthen the perimeter of their empire, and perhaps make the war so costly the United States would accept a negotiated peace leaving them with it.


Yet for all that, this year once again I find little or no mention of Midway in the news media.  The men who fought the war continue to die off, and soon will all be dead. The memory of what they did should not. Writing about it every year or so seems the least a person ought to do. 

Labels: , ,

Monday, December 09, 2013

Thatcher and Mandela

Margaret Thatcher died this year at the age of 87. She was the first woman to head the elected government of a major European nation, serving as prime minister from 1979 to 1990. She played a major role in history and her actions were immensely beneficial to both her own country and the United States. In Great Britain she reversed many of the post-WWII trends policies which were turning that once prosperous and great nation into the sick man of Western Europe and set it on paths to recovery and prosperity. In foreign affairs she came into office at a time when the Soviet Union was advancing around the world, and the United States and its allies were losing the Cold War. The Soviets’ nuclear and other forces were growing stronger, while those of the United States and its allies remained static or grew weaker.   Many influential leaders of the foreign policy establishment on both sides of the Atlantic argued that the United States needed to accommodate itself to Soviet superiority and domination of Europe and accept second place status in the world. Almost all of them believed  the Soviet Union to be a stable, dynamic,  and  economically vigorous empire and considered  the notion of defeating the Soviets and liberating its conquered nations to be an absurd fantasy.  The facts of course turned out differently. Within a little more than a decade, the Cold War and its threat of nuclear war ended, the Soviet empire collapsed in total defeat, the nations of east central Europe were liberated, and much of the Soviet Union itself was partitioned from Russia into a number of smaller states – all without bloodshed.  It was a world historical triumph which finally ended the 20th Century European nightmare that began in 1914 and created opportunities for a more stable, peaceful, and prosperous Europe and world.  Ronald Reagan was the main force behind this remarkable reversal of fortune in the world, and Margaret Thatcher was his strongest and most influential ally. She deserves a significant amount of the credit for making it happen, and as such did more  to help the United States than any foreign leader since Winston Churchill.

Yet when she died, the administration of Barack Obama churlishly failed to acknowledge her accomplishments or significance (or to bother with her funeral), and lots of Obama’s ideological allies seemed mainly to celebrate the fact that she was finally dead.  
  
Nelson Mandela died a few days ago at the age of 95. He was president of South Africa from 1994 to 1999. Some military strategists considered South Africa to have some strategic importance during the Cold War because of its position at the junction of the Atlantic and Indian oceans, but events in the country generally have had little effect on the United States. Before becoming president, Mandela was a leader of a revolutionary movement opposing the Boers’ apartheid regime.  Apartheid was a policy of forced racial segregation, denial of civil and voting rights to non-whites including the right to travel freely,  and harsh suppression of opposition from any source. It deserved the contempt and condemnation it received around the world. Mandela was involved to some degree with violent efforts to overthrow the government and is said to have joined the Communist party for a while. He was arrested and charged with trying to overthrow the government through violence. He spent over twenty years in prison, much  of that time in harsh conditions. The Boers eventually realized that they could not continue apartheid and released Mandela and other prisoners.  Mandela became president and presided over the dismantling of apartheid.  South Africa did not collapse into either the barbarism of Central Africa or the Marxist disaster of Zimbabwe, and Mandela deserves credit for that. It was a significant accomplishment. He ignored his socialist ideology and did not nationalize any industries or companies, and he opposed plans for oppressing the whites, even the ones who had been active in the oppressive former government. South Africa became a corrupt, crime ridden country with bitter and often violent tribal and racial conflicts, but one far more successful than most of the rest of Africa.  


To call it a real success  or to claim what happens in South Africa is important to the United States would require setting  the bar very low. That, however, is the essence of affirmative action, and likely a reason the Obama administration and its supporters in the traditional media  are serving up hagiography and treating this as an almost cosmic event. The other main reason is probably affinity for Mandela's ideology.  The contrast with their dismissive behavior when Thatcher died is interesting and telling.  

Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, October 09, 2013

Across the Wide Missouri

Bernard DeVoto was an author and editor who worked in the first half of the 20th Century. He wrote several works about Mark Twain and was the editor of a volume of Twain’s mainly unpublished works Letters from the Earth. He was also a historian of the early days of the American west.  I have just finished reading his book Across the Wide Missouri which deals mainly with the mountain men and fur companies of  the west in the 1830’s and the Indians they encountered but also covers the  Whitmans and other early missionaries to the Indians.

It is a fine and interesting book on a colorful and fascinating subject. DeVoto is a good writer, a thorough and  scrupulous collector of information, and a thoughtful and reasonable historian who makes a thoughtful and reasonable effort to separate fact from myth and tall tales and to be fair while still having an obvious point of view. He clearly admires the mountain men but does not romanticism them. He equally clearly is put off by the priggishness and  self righteousness of many of the missionaries but still recognizes their importance in history and their remarkable commitment and dedication.  He seems somewhat less fair when writing about the fur companies  (it was the 1940’s, and DeVoto was a colleague of Arthur Schlesinger, Jr.),  but even there he generally gives them their due, and some of the things the companies did were pretty rough.

His treatment of the Indians is particularly noteworthy. While he is sympathetic to them and fully aware of the raw deals they got and the doleful consequences of their encounter with 19th century civilization, he avoids the silly, Manichean ultra-Rousseauianism so popular in the last few years. His Indians are not presented as noble savages, pacifists, proto-ecologists, philosophers, or fonts of profound insights coincidentally dovetailing perfectly with the present day’s politically correct conventional wisdom. (There was enough of that even his time that he lampoons it a bit.) Instead he tries to show them as they really were -  a Neolithic, superstitious, often warlike people with complex and varied habits and traits, some admirable and some not, and with significant differences among the tribal groups. He tries to tell the truth about the Indians and their interactions with the whites and with each other.  (His thorough and convincing debunking of the myth of smallpox epidemics among Indians being caused intentionally, usually by infected blankets, is  a good example.)   


The book is also just fun. DeVoto writes with good humor. His prose is lively, and he likes a good yarn, even the ones he points out as false. I recommend it. For people weary of the boring and tendentious leftist morality plays that often masquerade as works of history today, it should be an especially welcome change.  His book The Year of Decision 1846 is also good. 

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Seeing Obama Clearly


A devout Baptist expired in his sleep one night and awakened happily to find himself in heaven. While looking around and taking in his surroundings, he noticed an old, white bearded fellow outfitted in cowboy boots and a ten gallon hat strutting around, barking out orders, and generally behaving in an overbearing manner.
“Who’s that?” he asked the person next to him.
“Oh,” the person replied,  “that’s God. He thinks he’s Lyndon Johnson.”
old joke circa mid-1960’s



Change the costume a bit, and you would have a perfectly good Obama joke, fitting his  personality and ideology as well as the old one did Johnson’s. In many ways there really is not that much new or different about Obama. Regardless of the fear mongering of conservative pundits and the fantasies of his press agents in the traditional media, Obama is not a historic man of destiny, reshaping the nation  to his will. He is not Napoleon (he just has the complex). He’s not even Mussolini, despite the remarkably similar jutting of the chin. He is just a typical American leftist doing what leftists do when they get the chance, as a quick look at history can help to illustrate.

Roosevelt’s New Deal prolonged the depression and left the nation’s economy in many ways more hamstrung and regulated and its bureaucracy more powerful than today. The country was definitively far more union-ridden, and Roosevelt’s attacks on business, success,  and wealth make Obama’s seem mild.  Certainly none of Obama’s questionable or even illegal executive orders comes close to Roosevelt’s sending a whole class of innocent, loyal Americans to concentration camps by executive decree.

 Johnson’s left wing agenda and authoritarian vision were at least as grandiose as Obama’s, and he was far better at getting his plans enacted into law. He was fully as arrogant and power mad as Obama, and his corruption and abuses of power were perhaps greater. (As an aside he was probably also slightly more vulgar.)

 Though Carter’s ideology and failures are obvious and well known, people sometimes forget that the celebrated moderation of the later years of Clinton’s administration was a result of and a pragmatic reaction to political defeat. In the first couple of years when he was proposing the things he actually wanted, Clinton was about as far to the left as Obama has been. Hillarycare, his  most important proposal,  was more socialistic and authoritarian than Obamacare – Obamacare for example having, as far as we know, no provisions for criminal penalties for people selecting their own doctors.

While we can accept that some of Obama’s notions, hatreds, and desires may be unusual, his actions and behavior are mainly typical of the American left when it gets power. He is doing what leftists usually do. He is harming those leftists usually harm. He is favoring those leftists usually favor. During his first two years in office, he had the votes in congress to run roughshod at least some of the time. He no longer does. Obamacare is a mess that will have to be fixed or repealed some day. It is not permanent or politically untouchable.  His opponents need to keep their heads. He is a crafty, dedicated enemy of liberty and limited government who should not be taken lightly. He is not Attila, the booger man, or the destroyer of the republic. Those conservatives who paint him as such overate him as much as he and  his sycophants do and play into his hand. What is needed is a clear headed recognition  that he is  another dangerous  opponent, one to be taken seriously and opposed seriously, but not one to be panicked or awed by. A little less gloom and a few more good, offensive jokes might be a good place to start.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, November 08, 2012

1980 and 2012


My generation, the boomers, has been a lucky one. Today, after an election that probably means some rough luck for the country, it is appropriate to honor the man who was responsible for much of our good luck. Thirty two years ago in 1980 the country was in much worse shape  than it is today. The economy was in a debilitating inflationary depression with double digit inflation and high unemployment. Mortgage and other interest rates were in the mid teens.  The country was in a losing Cold War struggle with an aggressive and expansionist Soviet Union. Statist, anti-growth, left wing policies had dominated recent administrations of both parties, and pundits of all sorts were pronouncing that the nation was in a terminal decline. 

That November the country  elected Ronald Reagan president and gave his party a majority in the senate. He gave the government new policies, new directions, and a new viewpoint. Within a few years inflation came under control;  interest rates declined; anti-growth policies were changed; and the nation began a quarter century of growth and prosperity. The Soviet Union was completely defeated in the Cold War, and the occupied nations in central and eastern Europe were liberated.

We early boomers got to spend much of our working years  in times that were more prosperous, more full of opportunity, and freer from the threat of nuclear war than almost anyone would have guessed in 1980 – a lucky bunch of people indeed. Reagan gave us peace and a quarter century respite from many of the depredations of rapacious government, and many of us used that respite to put the lie to the commonplace belief of 1980 that  most of our generation would have less success and lower standards of living than their parents. Now, the country is again plagued by statist, anti-growth, left wing policies and has just re-elected a president in the mold of Jimmy Carter and Richard Nixon.

We can be grateful indeed for the respite Reagan helped give us and hope that our children and grandchildren will someday be as lucky. We owe it to them to try to make that happen. We also owe it to them and ourselves to use our wealth, knowledge, and experience to prepare for the possible rough times ahead and to help the people we care about get through them as well as they can.

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Colin Powell


Colin Powell made the news a few days  ago by endorsing Obama for re-election . This was neither a surprise nor news. Obama’s cheerleaders in the  traditional media  did not even try to make it a big deal, as they had done with his double crossing McCain in 2008. Powell, a man who perhaps could have become president in 1996, is fading from the scene and from the public’s awareness.

History, I think, should see him as America’s  most over rated  general since Douglas MacArthur, and a man whose overall impact on the nation was harmful. It was Powell the general who helped persuade the first President Bush to stop action in the first war in Iraq in the midst of a rout that would have removed Hussein from power and eliminated any pretext for a second war. Later, it was Powell the politician who made the case to the public for an unnecessary second war in Iraq on the basis of claims the Iraqi government had dangerous weapons no one ever found. It was Powell who supported and perhaps helped sell the administration of George W. Bush on nation building in Iraq and Afghanistan (“you break it, you fix it”),  leading to years of futile effort, bloodshed,  and cost with no legitimate  purpose. Then after things went obviously bad in those efforts, he turned on his benefactors and recast himself as an opponent of the wars and occupations he had supported, helped start, and urged prolonging.

His career calls to mind, not Eisenhower or Grant, but rather MacArthur and George McClellan, two other political generals who for a time enjoyed fame and reputation far beyond their accomplishments and who also had their trouble with loyalty.  

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Forgetting History

World War II is fading from people’s memory as surely as its veterans are fading from the scene. That fact seems particularly odd to those of my generation. We boomers grew up in the shadow of that war. Most of our fathers served in it. The years of our childhood and youth were commonly called the post-war era. The books, movies, TV shows, and comics we read and saw were full of stories from the war. Even as children we understood that it had been a life changing event for our parents, and as we grew older we learned what it meant for the life of the country and the history of the world. Now we see generations of Americans to whom the Second World War is apparently as remote and dimly understood as the war with Spain in 1898. It’s strange and sad and I think wrong that the awareness and understanding are fading so much and so quickly.
I thought of this today when I noticed the absence of notice in the media of the fact that this is the 70th anniversary of one of the most important events of World War II – the Nazi invasion of the Soviet Union and the start of the war on the eastern front in Europe. The four years of battles that followed that invasion were among the bloodiest and most brutal in history, and their ultimate outcome did much to determine the course of the war and the shape of the post-war world. The crimes and atrocities committed in eastern Europe by the Nazis until they were defeated in 1945 and by the Soviets until the collapse of their empire almost fifty years later were among the most horrible in history. It’s not an anniversary or a story we should be forgetting.

Labels: , ,

Monday, May 02, 2011

Charles Goodnight

Charles Goodnight led one of the legendary Texas lives. Born in 1836 only three days after Texas declared independence, he was a frontier scout, a Texas Ranger in the Comanche wars, a trail driver and trail blazer, a cattle breeder and raiser, a philanthropist, an early conservationist, and the founder of the first great ranch in the Texas panhandle before he died at ninety three in 1929. He owned herds in the thousands of head that ranged over spreads of dozens of thousands of acres. There is a small town in the panhandle named after him, and the Goodnight and Loving trail was a well known subject to Texas school children in the days when they were taught the state’s history. Several of the characters and events in the book Lonesome Dove including the return of the partner’s body to Texas, the great cattle drive to northern ranges, the character of the cowboy Deets, and the barefoot trek across country to get help for a wounded man seem to be lifted pretty much directly from Goodnight’s experiences. The character Woodrow Call bears a strong resemblance to Goodnight himself.

The book Charles Goodnight Cowman and Plainsman is a lengthy biography of Goodnight by the historian J. Evetts Haley. Haley had the advantage of knowing Goodnight during the last years of the rancher’s life, and much of the material comes from Goodnight’s own recollections. He tells a fascinating and compelling story that should be enjoyed by anyone interested in the West, in the history of Texas, or just in a good story about the dynamic and interesting life of a great figure in a rough and unsettled frontier. He does a good job of bringing to life times now seeming ever more remote. I liked the book a lot.

My only serious criticism of the book is that the author does not always do a good job of keeping things straight and clear with respect to chronology. A reader may at times have to wonder too much about exactly what things happened when and before or after what others. Still it is a fine book about an interesting life and a wonderful time.

Labels: , ,