Monday, March 06, 2023

Affirmative Action

 

The original stated idea of affirmative action was that people hiring employees, recruiting students, or looking for vendors or contractors should consider not only the types of people they had done business with in the past but also look for and at people from other groups and backgrounds. However it quickly became a de facto and sometimes explicit and official quota system under which people and organizations satisfied the government by selecting people based on their race and sometimes sex. As such it is a bad policy that should be eliminated.


In the first place it goes against the reason discrimination is wrong – the principle that people should not be discriminated against by race, sex, or ethnicity but should be judged as individuals on their merit and qualities. The argument that quotas are necessary to correct past discrimination does not work after over fifty years. Affirmative action now punishes people who have not discriminated against anyone and rewards people who have not been discriminated against.


It usually lowers overall quality by at least some amount in situations and organizations where it is practiced. If filling the quota is the priority, then other criteria, such as competence and ability, are necessarily secondary. It would be a  coincidence for the group of people in a beneficiary class selected to fill a quota to be the same as the group of people from that class seeking selection who would have been successful if judged on merit. And in  cases where such a coincidence did occur, affirmative action would have been superfluous. (The same lessening of quality of course occurs with selections based on other things unrelated to merit such as legacy, connections, nepotism, and having been someone’s frat brother.)


Affirmative action also is  unfair to competent people in the beneficiary classes who didn’t need it and got ahead on their own. It leads others to wonder if they are good enough to be where they are or are only “affirmative action hires” – a term commonly used to denote a less competent or even incompetent person selected to fill a quota. There are people who, knowing nothing else about them, would rather use a white or Asian doctor or contractor than a black one, solely because they know he or she got there without a boost from quotas and lower standards. That is a sad situation.


I hope the supreme court ends affirmative action in admissions to colleges that get government money, and that it ends in other places as well. The country would be better off for it.




Labels: ,

Thursday, August 03, 2017

Admission to Colleges

This week at the White House a reporter asked the press secretary if people in the administration thought affirmative action policies at colleges discriminated against white students in a manner suggesting holding such an opinion would be at least a hideous breach of etiquette and probably something far worse.  (The question was probably inspired by  information leaked  to the New York Times about  Department of Justice hiring lawyers to look into the question of discrimination in admissions to colleges and by the reactions to it of  various Democratic politicians and their friends.  It turned out that the investigation apparently will deal with claims of discrimination against Asian students. The Times missed that, whether carelessly or perhaps on the premise that its audience would appreciate the evil of the thing more readily if the possible beneficiaries were white.)

The accepted  hypocrisies and taboos  of a society require that certain things not be publicly mentioned or considered even if they are not only  true but  obviously so.  Affirmative action in college admissions is a good example. Admission policies  which set lower standards   for black and Hispanic applicants than for white and Asian ones discriminate against the latter two. By excluding them from admission, these policies harm all white and Asian applicants  whose qualifications are below the white/Asian acceptance point(s)  but above the black/Hispanic one(s).   It is possible to argue honestly (though I think wrongly) that such discrimination is a good thing, but it is not possible to argue honestly that the discrimination does not exist.  If person A has higher overall qualifications for admission  than person B before  the race of either is considered  but is rejected while B is accepted once  the race of each is considered, then A has been discriminated against on the basis of race.


The dust up this week illustrates how well accepted the hypocrisy and taboo on this issue are. It also indicates more than a little fear among those who favor something they may not be able to defend. 

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, April 20, 2016

Twenty Dollar Bill

It is often interesting and informative when people descend into unintentional self-parody. A good recent example is the government’s decision to replace Andrew Jackson on the twenty dollar bill with Harriet Tubman. The essence of affirmative action is the act of rewarding individuals from favored groups solely on the basis of their membership in those groups and equating their modest abilities and accomplishments to the greater abilities and accomplishments of individuals not in the groups. (People of real ability and accomplishment from favored groups do not need affirmative action and are often unfairly tarred by assumptions that they owe their success to it.)

Tubman was one of many brave people who worked with the underground railroad to rescue slaves in the south and transport them to safety in the north. That is commendable, but she was only one of many and, in fact, did far less to end slavery than her contemporary who shared her first name Harriet Beecher Stowe.

Now consider the other people pictured on American currency.  George Washington was literally the father of the nation. He commanded American forces during the revolution, chaired the convention which created the constitution, declined an opportunity to become king, and as the first president set  the nation firmly on course as a constitutional republic.

Thomas Jefferson wrote  the Declaration of Independence, worked for a bill of rights in the constitution, supported laws protecting religious freedom, attempted to end slavery, was an important inventor, scientist, author, and architect, and secured the nation and doubled its size by making the Louisiana Purchase.

Abraham Lincoln saved the Union, guided the nation to victory in the Civil War, and ended slavery.

Alexander Hamilton was a leader of the revolution and a skilled administrator who is credited with putting the new American government’s finances on sound footing and preventing it from financial collapse.

Ulysses S. Grant as a military commander won the Civil War for the Union army by first defeating the Confederacy in the west and then overcoming the formerly unbeatable army of Robert E. Lee in the east. Later as president his was the only administration for almost a hundred years to try to protect the rights of black Americans in the south.

Benjamin Franklin was perhaps the most famous scientist of the late 18th Century, an accomplished author, a talented inventor, a successful diplomat and  a leader of the revolution and a founder of the nation.

Equating Tubman to these men in historical importance is  an example of affirmative action in action  which easily reaches the level of self-parody.

None of this is intended to defend Andrew Jackson. He is a mixed figure. He did some very good things such as defeating the British at New Orleans. He also did some very bad things such as creating the modern Democratic party.


Labels: , ,

Monday, June 09, 2014

Revoked?

There is a phenomenon in government, large businesses and non-profit organizations which some people call the affirmative action pass. It is the tacit understanding that one must not demand performance or professionalism from an affirmative action hire matching that required of those hired by ordinary means, but rather must apply lower standards to and refrain from public criticism of a person hired under affirmative action.  (This of course does not mean that everyone hired under affirmative action  is less competent or professional than the norm. Clearly many are not and would have been perfectly qualified for their positions in the absence of affirmative action and may be unfairly suspected of being less qualified than their peers because of affirmative action.  It just means that those who need the pass often get it.) 

There are various reasons for this. One is fear of getting into trouble. Part of the game in affirmative action is pretending lower standards do not lead to lower performance.  Many organizations have enforcers in human resources or diversity departments who try to make sure this orthodoxy does not get questioned without consequences. There is also often  a deeper fear, one which is often mingled with guilt, at work  – the fear of being seen as prejudiced and being labeled a racist.  Then there is the simple general tendency of people to go along with the prevailing winds and do and think what they are told.

Throughout his candidacy and presidency, Barack Obama  has been a beneficiary of something similar to an affirmative action pass. His supporters have claimed that any criticism of his performance is secretly based on racial prejudice, and too many of his opponents have cringed and eased up in ways they would not have done otherwise. Many Americans have been reluctant to give up on Obama or to hold him to ordinary standards of performance out of fear of being seen as prejudiced or guilt over not supporting the first black president. People in the traditional media have been incessant in extolling and excusing Obama and fanning up prevailing breezes in his favor.


The interesting thing in the last couple of months, is that with the scandal at the VA and the release of dangerous  terrorists in exchange for a deserter, Obama’s pass seems to have been revoked.  More people, including even people in the  traditional media, are now treating him and evaluating him on his performance more nearly as  they would any other president. That is bad news for him and his followers. 

Labels: , ,

Thursday, July 18, 2013

Race and Guilt

Various thinkers have written about the harm done to people by guilt and its attendant sense of unworthiness. Some have noted particularly the crippling effects of inappropriate and undeserved feelings of guilt on decent people who  haven’t done anything wrong and thus the desirability for would be tyrants of making those they wish to tyrannize feel guilty and sinful.   We can see a mild example of  this in this country with regard to race where a big part of the dishonest game being played by politicians, their allies in the traditional media,  and so called civil rights leaders depends on white people’s being guilt ridden enough to accept their impositions, rules, and demands cravenly and uncritically.

This requires getting  people to accept blame  for something they never did.  Jim Crow segregation laws and government rules were abolished over time in the United States in the two decades following World War II. By 1964 they were gone completely.  The voting age at that time was twenty one. So no one under the age of seventy today voted for segregation laws or the (almost all Democratic) politicians who created and maintained them because none of them could have,  and a majority of the people now over seventy did nothing to support Jim Crow either. They  have nothing to feel guilty or blameworthy about on the issue and should realize it. (In fact the only government imposed racial discrimination in the adult lives of anyone born after World War II  has been the direct, explicit, and systematic discrimination of the last forty years  in favor of blacks and, to some degree,  Hispanics and against whites and others in the form of affirmative action quotas, rules, double standards, and mandates. That this discrimination has been nowhere nearly as damaging or severe as that which black people endured under Jim Crow does not make it right.  It just makes it less bad.)

 Things are even clearer with respect to slavery. The last surviving former slaveholder has been dead a very long time. Most died over a hundred years ago.  No one alive today bears any responsibility for the crimes of slavery. The supporters and defenders of slavery (again almost all Democrats) paid for their crimes with death and destruction in the Civil War.  Much of the wealth stolen by slaveholders from the labor of slaves, which wealth was never spread widely among southern whites, was destroyed in that war. Today’s white Americans  are no more to blame for slavery than today’s Italians are for  Caesar’s conquest of Gaul.


None of this is meant to ignore or diminish the wrongs done to black Americans in the past or to deny that the some of the harm done in the past has had lingering effects.  Rather it is to say only that innocent people should not accept guilt or punishment when they have done nothing wrong. Americans need to reject both the punitive policies of the politicians and bureaucrats and the strictures of hypocritical political correctness. News and events of the last few days illustrate the need to do so.  

Labels: , , ,

Friday, April 27, 2012

Diversity (University Style) Defined

As the Supreme Court is about to hear a case from the University of Texas on the permissibility of basing admissions to universities on race, we will hear a lot of talk about a supposed need for diversity. In the context of affirmative action at colleges and universities, the term “diversity” is used with a particular meaning. It does not  refer to the desirable goal of creating a community of active discourse and widely diverse opinions where students are exposed to a variety of viewpoints  and theories, but rather to something quite different. Diversity is to plain, direct, race-quota based patronage as creation science is to plain, old fashioned  creationism,  that is a fundamentally intellectually dishonest fallback and expedient developed for public consumption after the actual belief becomes untenable.

Labels: , ,