Wednesday, April 17, 2024

Two Old Tales for Tax Week

 

Here in tax week and apropos of nothing really, I recalled a couple of stories about citizen’s interactions with our nation’s public servants. The first was told to me twenty five or more years ago by a man who was old then and is probably long since dead now. I don’t recall his name, and so I’ll call him Smith. One day years before he told me the story, Smith and his wife were being rudely threatened and insulted in their home by a nasty IRS agent wearing a green sports jacket. At one point the agent turned to Smith and said “do your realize I can throw you in jail?”. Being something of a hard head, Smith replied “do you realize I can blow your brains out?”. The agent then left in a hurry. Smith then picked up the phone, called the local IRS office, and warned them that there was a man in a green sports jacket going around town impersonating an IRS agent and threatening people. According to Smith that was the end of affair, and he never heard any more from the IRS.


The second was told me over thirty years ago by a colleague named Bob. Bob lived out in the country in the plains of west Texas. He enjoyed guns and shooting and decided it would be fun to become gun dealer. He filed his application with the ATF, and eventually an agent named Chauncey showed up to interview him. He took Chauncey out to the small out building behind his house which he intended to use as his store. Bob had applied for an ordinary license to deal in sporting and personal arms, but somehow in the bureaucracy his application had been coded as one for a license to deal in weapons of war. When Chauncey asked Bob what he would be doing with a license to sell such weapons, Bob, instead of explaining the error, decided to have a little fun. He stepped outside and pointed to the flat plains around him and said “well I guess I’m not going to be selling them to the communists in the hills”. That was a mistake. Chauncey was not amused, but eventually the error was corrected, and Bod got his license.


I believe Bob’s story. It sounded just like him. I’m more skeptical of Mr. Smith’s tale, but both are interesting yarns.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, August 25, 2022

Hurt Feelings at the IRS

 

Among the very bad things coming from American leftists in the last few years is the notion that rude speech is violence – that harsh or nasty criticism is equivalent to physical assault. As with many other things from the leftists, it is false, phony, and dangerous. The falseness is obvious. The damage from sticks and stones is of a different category from hurt feelings from harsh words. The phoniness is obvious as well. Leftists clearly do not really mean it, at least not as a general principle. They apply their maxim to “hateful” criticism of people and things they like, but almost never to the things they and those they approve of say about people and causes they dislike. The danger is that leftists in power will use the idea to violate their opponents rights to speech and opinion.


Something like this is coming from the Internal Revenue Service. Several IRS employees and friends of the agency in the media have attempted to  conflates political criticism of the  agency from Republicans  and others with threats to attack  agents or offices. It may not fully be an attempt to equate dissent with criminal activity, but it comes  close enough. Someone needs to tell them  that this is in the United States of America and not central Europe in the 1930s, and that criticizing, disliking, or even despising the IRS or the people in power in Washington at any particular time is the right of every American citizen. It’s in the Constitution. And as a pragmatic matter, officials might want to consider whether having people speaking for the  IRS attack one political party might lead even the more gullible members of the public to question the claim that the IRS is an apolitical organization which enforces tax laws fairly and consistently with no political favoritism or prejudice.


Labels: , ,

Tuesday, August 09, 2022

More IRS Agents

 People who say taxation is theft are of course right. The income tax is the moral equivalent of feudal barons seizing the food raised by their serfs. The property tax is the moral equivalent of 1920s Chicago gangsters shaking down shopkeepers for protection money. The estate tax is the moral equivalent of one of the slimy bounty hunters in The Wild Bunch asking another for his knife because one of the corpses of the men they had just killed had some gold in his teeth. All governments are funded by criminal activity.


This does not mean there should be no governments. In a world where enough people were fair, just, rational, and honest, there would be no need for governments and thus no need for taxes. We do not live in such a world. In this world police, courts, armed forces for national defense, and various other activities of government are necessary and make Americans more free than the would be in their absence (Rothbardian fantasies notwithstanding). It does mean that people should be skeptical of their governments, that many things that can be done voluntarily should be, and that the amount of criminal activity by the state should be kept to a minimum.


This week the Democrats decided that what this country needs to solve its problems is eighty-seven thousand more tax collectors and passed a law authorizing hiring them. They tried to pass it off as a scheme to squeeze only rich people but voted down amendments requiring that the new hires would molest only the rich. So one may assume they will be coming after plenty of other than rich people. With Trump still around it sometimes is difficult for people to remember the Republicans usually are less bad than the Democrats. This bill is a reminder. Claims that only “cheaters” have anything to worry about are nonsense. Federal tax laws are so vague and complex and subject to capricious individual bureaucratic interpretation that even conscientious taxpayers can get tripped up in audits, sometimes after relying on a statement by one IRS employee that the auditor decides to contradict. (The IRS states explicitly that reliance on what one has been told by one of its employees is no defense.) There is also plenty of evidence that people and organizations whose political views dissent from those of the Democrats will have a lot to worry about. One can guess that interpretations of things in gray areas will not be going their way. Even an audit that results in no charges is unpleasant enough for the threat of being selected for one because of one’s political opinions to be a good tool for keeping political dissidents quieter. Then there is the simple fact of adding eighty-seven thousand people who want to work as tax collectors to the government’s payroll. Without going too far into that, it is enough to ask what sort of person would seek a career as a shakedown artist, and whether we want thousands more of them running around with authority to harm others.


It seems likely that Republicans will take control of the house and the senate this fall. If so, the appropriations they pass should defund the eighty-seven thousand and shrink the IRS back to its present size or smaller.








Labels: , ,

Wednesday, August 05, 2020

More From Trump

Donald Trump is a jackass who has no business being president of the United States. Of the sixteen other people who sought the Republican nomination in 2016,  at least fourteen would have been a better choice, and an easy half dozen would have been a far better choice.  Republicans have a lot to answer for for the way they picked their candidate that year. He was elected only because the Democrats nominated someone who was worse – both as a candidate with plans and objectives and as a human being.

In the last week he has given the country two more example of how unfit for the job he is. In one of his tweets he outrageously suggested postponing the election because of the epidemic.  This country has never postponed and election, and a president has no power to postpone one. The country held the presidential election of 1864 during  a bloody rebellion and civil war. It held the presidential election of 1944 during a world war.  If as seems likely,  Trump meant the tweet to be taken seriously, it shows his ignorance, arrogance, power mania, and contemptuous disregard for law, limited government, and the Constitution. If he was joking, as some Republicans have hopefully or nervously suggested, it shows a buffoonish lack of dignity and understanding of the need for powerful people to be careful and thoughtful in what they say.

He has since delivered more of the same by declaring that if he does not get his way on a moratorium on or a reduction of social security taxes, he has the power to suspend the tax by decree.  It is not unfair to wonder whether he has forgotten, never learned, or simply does not care that the Constitution gives the congress the power to determine taxes.

He is at least as arrogant and power hungry as his predecessor, and less smooth in how he goes about it. Unfortunately he is also the person one should hope wins the election in November. Instead of offering moderate proposals and plans, the Democrats have adopted a dangerous and harmful leftist agenda (and with a candidate who is likely demented to boot), making it necessary for people who believe in individual rights and limited government to oppose them. That means voting for Republicans and supporting Trump’s reelection as the lesser evil, because overall his policies have been and his proposals and plans are far better than those of the Democrats. It is a hell of a note, bit it is what we’ve got. Neither an Ike, nor a  JFK, nor a Reagan, nor even  a Dole or a Humphrey will on the ballot for either party.


Labels: , ,

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Tax Reform


I preface by noting both that I realize that there is no such thing as fairness in taxation, that taxation is  theft governed by the law of the jungle, and that government is a necessary evil that should be kept as small as possible. The best taxation policy would be to shrink government to its proper functions and then argue about what sort of taxes should support that much smaller entity. However, I also realize that most of my countrymen disagree with me, and that such a large shrinkage is not likely to happen anytime soon. (We may get lucky and get back to something like the situation in the Clinton administration after the next election, but anything better seems a long way off.)  That being so, it might be a good idea to look at the present tax code and see what could be done to make it a bit simpler and less crippling and perverse.  

The personal income tax is usually the first one people think about. Here simplification has potential benefits apart from removing perverse incentives and economic distortions in reducing the money and man hours spent annually on tax preparation and compliance, money and time that almost no one outside the accounting business would see as productively spent. A significant  simplification would be to have a system treating all sorts of income as nearly equally as politically possible  with as few brackets as politically possible.  

In the line of treating all income equally, it would make sense to tax dividends and capital gains at the same rate as other income.  Leftist critics of the present system are right about this. However it also makes sense to tax only real capital gains, not phantom ones due purely to inflation. A solution would be to convert the purchase basis of sold assets to an equivalent value in present dollars using a table of inflation rates and pay tax at one’s full rate on the difference between that more nearly accurate basis and the selling price.  There is also a problem in terms of equal treatment with dividends – the problem of double taxation. The corporation pays taxes on the earnings it distributes in dividends, and then the recipient pays income taxes on those dividends.  A solution here would be either not to tax the corporation on dividends (since the corporation does not keep the money but merely passes it through to stockholders)  or to tax both the corporation and the recipient on half of the dividend at the full tax rate (which would deal with the supposed problem of the money being completely untaxed if the recipient were tax exempt).


Then  there are the deductions, most of which would be good targets for elimination if one’s goal were simplicity and equal treatment. The deduction for state and local income taxes is an obvious one to kill. It is hard to see anything particular about that  tax that should earn  it special treatment not given to other taxes collected by states, counties, and cities. The deduction  serves chiefly to make the state and local bite a bit less burdensome for rich people living in California,  New York City, and a few other high  tax locales.  That also may explain why it has never been touched. On the surface there is more to support the deduction for property  taxes on homes, since having  a higher proportion of property owners in the population  is generally a good thing, and this deduction is supposed to make buying a house easier.  The same arguments support the deduction for interest paid on mortgages.  However, given the fairly high present standard deduction, both seem in practice  to be more tax breaks for wealthier people buying expensive houses than help for middle income people to afford a house. This is also the case for the deduction for vacation homes. Besides it is not  easy to find reasons  that a renter should necessarily pay more taxes than a mortgagor with the same income. A portion of his rent certainly goes to cover the interest and property tax expenses of the landlord.


The present exemption for the employee for health insurance paid by the employer is one that never should have existed in the first place, since its unintended consequence of  tying health coverage to one’s job is one of the main  causes of the present mess in health care in the country.  The same goes to a lesser extent for the various other types of insurance offered in company’s cafeteria plans. 

IRA’s, 401’s, and their various cousins present an interesting problem. The simplest course would be to eliminate their tax benefits since they seem to serve mainly as benefits for savings by prudent people who would have saved anyway.  It is not clear  that very many irresponsible people  are persuaded to save by the tax breaks. A  counter argument is that even the careless get old, and that at least the mandatory and company funded plans should keep their favored treatment. This would make more people less dependent on social security, which would have benefits. Either way  there would need to be a transition period when money already in these plans was treated as promised.


Ending deductions for charitable contributions would be controversial, but there are good reasons for doing so, starting with the fact that the organized charities and non-profit organizations are already advantaged in the tax code by being tax exempt themselves. Additionally, given the large standard deduction, the biggest benefits from the deduction go to wealthier people. Also from the viewpoint of equal  treatment and effectiveness, it is hard to see why the tax code should disfavor a direct donation to poor or needy people in comparison  to one funneled through a organization that takes its own cut before the recipient of the charity sees anything. (Right now, for example, if someone buys an impoverished  single mother a presentable outfit to wear to a job interview or gives a poor college freshman a few hundred bucks to help with the cost of books, it is certainly a charitable contribution, but not a deductable one.)


Doing all this would lead to a simpler income tax for individuals and to some quite low yet revenue neutral  tax rates. I think it would also be less distortive and deliver fewer unintended consequences. The next step would be to hack into the jungle that is business and corporate accounting and tax law. That’s where it would get really complicated.  However simplifications and benefits could  be had there as well, over time.


Of course none of this is likely. Politicians seem to like the present mess and enjoy both the present tax code and offering favored constituents ways to finesse it .

Labels: , ,

Friday, August 20, 2010

Closing the Library

It is fairly standard procedure for state and local politicians, whenever faced with having less money available than they want to spend, to resort to the old trick of closing the library, i.e. selecting something they do that many taxpayers actually like and benefit from and announcing, reluctantly, that they will have to cut way back on it unless they get some sort of tax increase. The people running public school districts are masters of this. They usually greet any shortfall in their budgets with dire warning about having to lay teachers off, stop patching roofs, and quit serving milk in the school cafeterias while remaining utterly silent about possible cost savings from eliminating frivolous or unproductive activities and reducing the number of administrators, co-coordinators, counselors, third deputy activity directors and other bureaucrats who never enter a classroom.

Sad to say, this sort of thing usually works. The politicians and bureaucrats make their threats. They receive a sympathetic chorus from the press, complete with outrageous sob stories if possible, and generally after a while get their way. Not enough taxpayers are astute enough to ask what fraction of the budget the library (or the city park or the fire department or the state police or whatever has been selected) makes up, what alternative cuts could be made in other departments, and what cost savings would be possible through increased efficiency, elimination of “services” that add no value, and reducing headcount in the various administrative and bureaucratic areas instead of among the people who actually do the work in those departments that actually do something useful.

Exceptions to this become more likely during times when the taxpayers are also feeling the pressure of economic difficulty. Thus one of the good things that can come out of recessions is a chance to cut back on the cancerous growth of state and local government. When recessions bite hard enough, the closing the library gambit may not work. Governments may have to make hard decisions under scrutiny and trim down at least a little of their fat and cut back a bit on their reach. One of the worst things about the so-called stimulus of the federal government is that it is preventing this from happening enough during the current recession by subsidizing state and local governments so that they will not face hard choices. Indeed, large parts of the stimulus would be better labeled the No Bureaucrat Left Behind Act. This will have the effect of preventing needed pruning of state and local governments and making the eventual recovery less robust and the nation less prosperous.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Taxing Ourselves

I read an article a while back praising Seattle for being such a fine, progressive place where the citizens are willing to tax themselves for all sorts of civic improvements and “green” causes. Our city about to have a bond election, and I expect to hear local boosters talking about the need to tax ourselves for benefit of the community. Such talk is commonplace.

However it is completely wrong. People who vote for tax increases are not voting to tax themselves. If that were what they were doing, an election would be superfluous. All that would be needed would be a sign-up day where each person wishing to tax himself would be able to make a binding subscription of the amount he was to be assessed under the proposed tax. No, the purpose of such elections is not for people to vote to tax themselves, but for them to vote to tax their neighbors who disagree with them. It is a means for members of a group of people who want something to push some of the cost of achieving their desire onto unwilling people with other priorities by force. Fine talk of democracy and the will of the people notwithstanding, it is stealing, carefully masked and dolled up stealing to be sure, but still stealing.

Just as anyone who eats meat should be willing to kill the animal if necessary, anyone voting for a new or increased tax should be willing to shake his neighbors down at gunpoint to collect it, if necessary. That should set a high standard for bond and tax elections, one that few proposals will meet.

Labels: ,

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

News and Politics

The market has just taken out the lows of the 2000-2002 bear market and reached dozen year lows. This is completely understandable in term of a set of risks that are starting to resemble those of the 1970’s. In the short run we have a monetary crisis and a nasty recession that is pretty much worldwide. For the medium term we have a federal government that is operationally hostile to economic growth and the creation of wealth, as its tax, regulation, “fairness”, and “green” policies and proposals already clearly show. And in the long run we have a massive increase in the national debt, due to war and “stimulus”, just at the time when, because of the retirement of the boomers, we can least afford it. The last is particularly dangerous. In the 1970’s the government repudiated a large fraction of its debt through inflation, decimating the citizens’ savings of the post-WWII prosperity in the process. It then confiscated more of people’s savings by creating and taxing high nominal (though low or negative real) interest rates on those savings. There is every incentive for them to do it again now, particularly given that the party in power does not see savers or investors as part of its constituency. It is also important to remember that the inflationary depression of the 1970’s ended only when we got an inflation fighting fed, a pro-growth administration in Washington, and the explosive development of new companies and entire industries, many driven by innovations in technology. None of these things is on the horizon right now.

There is a lot of discussion about a crisis for people who are under water with their mortgages, and I find it puzzling. I understand the problems of those who are delinquent in their payments on mortgages, but I cannot see a crisis for most of those who are under water, but still making their payments. It is certainly unpleasant for a person’s house to be worth less on the market than the amount he owes on it. It makes the household balance sheet look bad, but unless a person sells the property, he does not have to cover any actual cash losses. He has the house he agreed to buy at the monthly payments he agreed to make. Eventually, as he pays down his debt and the real estate market turns, he will be above water again. After all, despite anything politicians or realtors might tell us, there really isn’t any natural or Constitutional right to annual appreciation in real estate.

The government announced last week that it was putting the squeeze on UBS to reveal names of its American depositors to the IRS. The news led to the usual bleating about “tax cheats” and “those not paying their fair share costing the rest of us”. Most of this is unseemly nonsense. A cheat is someone who defrauds another person or who breaks a rule of fairness or conduct to which he has agreed. Running from bandits or hiding from the tax collectors is not cheating. The question of whether to pay taxes is an almost purely pragmatic question, not a moral one. (There is a ethical issue about paying one’s share of the legitimate activities of the government and not being a free rider, but for most taxpayers that issue does not come up, because the government claims enough by withholding and through W-2’s and 1099’s to more than render that concern moot.) To claim otherwise is to assert that a government has an unlimited moral claim over people’s lives and efforts and that whatever it decides to take from them is right, solely because it has decided to take it. The point about “cheaters” increasing costs for the rest of us is no more valid. We need to remember that the problem for members a herd of gazelles being chased by a pack of hyenas is the hyenas, not the faster gazelles. We suffer harm at the hands of the tax collectors, not from our more nimble countrymen who avoid them. Besides, as a practical matter, does anyone believe that, if this government miraculously collected what it wants from all the “cheats”, it would lower taxes on everyone else? There is not much plausibility for that one.

Also last week, one our politicians admonished his fellow citizens for being cowards on the issue of race. He is of course right, though not in the way he meant. Our culture is deeply dishonest about race. Future generations likely will consider our hypocrisy and perversity on the question at least as harshly and ironically as many now view the attitudes of the Victorians on sex. We could take steps to become more honest. We could be sure we really do rate persons by their individual characteristics and not their ancestry. We could realize that one may criticize or even condemn a person’s acts or attitudes without having racial prejudice against him. We could reject undeserved guilt. The crimes of slavery and Jim Crow were egregious. No one alive today had anything to do with slavery. Only a few, in places such as the U. S. Senate, who played a role in Jim Crow are still alive. Those who had nothing to do with it need to refuse to accept guilt for something they did not do. That would make for more honesty, though probably not of the kind the politician wanted.

Labels: , , ,