Sunday, January 19, 2025

Laughing at the Jefe

 

I know many people are worried about the state of the republic. There are things to worry about - from Trump and company, from their opponents, and especially from authoritarian left and right wing enemies of the liberal order and liberal principles of individual rights. People who care about that order and those principles should expect to have to stand up and promote and defend them.


However, they should not let worry get the best of them or become too fearful. I agree with those who have pointed out how lucky we in America are to live in a country where the maximum jefe, in command of the armed forces and the federal secret police and prosecutors, announces he is altering the fundamental law of the nation by decree, and people just laugh at him, and nothing happens. It is still a great country. It would be a better one if we could create a political environment in which even a demented big chief and his gang would know better than to try such a stunt. But we should recognize and appreciate how well off we are.

Labels: ,

Friday, October 28, 2022

Getting a New Name

 

John Daniel Davidson is an editor at The Federalist. In a recent article he declared that he and other traditionalist authoritarians should stop calling themselves conservatives. If I were a conservative, I would agree and be happy to see them go.


Davidson claims that western civilization is dying, and is time for people of the right sort to take over the government and forcefully fix things. He sees no point in conservatives favoring the traditional family of a married man and wife raising their children if too many people prefer to live in other arrangements. He sees no value in freedom of religion if too many people disagree with his notions about religion. He warns that unless action is taken, pretty soon those who do not share his opinions will be numerous enough to start persecuting those who do.


He blames the technological changes of the last fifty years for the rise of moral relativism in the country (go figure) and objects to free markets, profit seeking technology outfits, and the people who favor them. He argues that to prevent “an implosion of Western civilization” it will be necessary to use government power to whip those capitalists and technologists into line.


In specifics he proposes to break up large technology companies, cut funding for universities, end no-fault divorce, subsidize (the right sort of) families with young children, outlaw abortions with no exceptions, arrest parents who take their children to events such as drag queen shows that he dislikes and charge them with child abuse, throw doctors who perform sex change surgeries or procedures in prison, and first fire and then prosecute teachers who expose students to sexually explicit material. It is a war, he says, and the warriors of righteousness “need not shy away from making these arguments because they betray some cherished libertarian fantasy about free markets and small governments.” As this list shows it is not only free markets that bother him. It is freedom itself.


I think he is right to stop calling himself a conservative. Conservatism in this country has usually meant something that to varying degrees of consistency has taken the principles of the Declaration of Independence seriously. His ideas have little common with the conservatism of people such as Reagan and Goldwater or that of many other conservatives now who generally like the idea of freedom and are often willing to mind their own business and let others mind theirs. (I can imagine Goldwater in particular telling the Davidsons of the country to go to hell.)


Of course Davidson and his people will need a name for themselves now that they no longer wish to be called conservatives. There is an obvious one, for both historical and ideological reasons. They should call themselves falangists. It fits.


Labels: , ,

Thursday, October 27, 2022

Alex Jones and Steve Bannon

 

Suppose someone in the media said that Democrats and their flacks in the traditional media almost gleefully used the murders at Sandy Hook to push a political agenda. Or suppose that someone said that the Democrats and their public relations people in the media exploited grieving parents of some of the victims to make political points by waving the bloody shirt, and that some of the parents were willing to be so exploited. Neither of these things would be defamation of the parents or anyone else (especially since both were true).


Then suppose that someone said without evidence that the murders were the result of a plot by the government, and the deranged murderer was put up to his crimes by federal agents provocateur. While that claim might be annoying to government officials and offensive to their friends in the media, it would not be defamation of the parents of the victims. It would just be another wacky conspiracy theory.


But suppose someone said to a large audience across the nation that the murders never happened, that the government staged fake murders for political reasons, and the parents of the victims were really actors aiding in the deception. That would be libelous, because it falsely accuses private citizens of participating in a fraud and a monstrous one at that. That is what Alex Jones did, and a judgment of libel was justified.


The amounts awarded were not. They were off by orders of magnitude. The amount of tangible harm Jones’s libel did to the parents was fairly small. They were rightly offended, but hurting people’s feelings is not the same as inflicting serious damage. Their careers were not destroyed. Their property was not harmed, and any possible damage to their reputations with the public was quickly repaired. Some parents said they were bothered and even harassed by obnoxious losers who believed the murders were a hoax, but it would be difficult to tie that activity directly to Jones.


It is likely the real reason for the huge judgments against Jones is not what he did but rather what he is. What he is is surely bad enough. He is a lying, disgusting demagogue and scoundrel. The things he said about the murders in Connecticut were the indecent and indefensible work of a vulgar lowlife. But nasty, even vile, people have the same civil rights as decent ones, and his penalty should have been based on his deeds rather than his character. Besides as a practical matter, smaller awards might have been fairly easily collectible, while Jones may try through bankruptcy to avoid paying quickly or even at all on the gigantic ones.


Steve Bannon was sentenced to a few months in jail this week for contempt of congress for refusing to honor a subpoena to testify in front of the January 6th committee of the house. Conservatives have pointed out that Democrat Eric Holder was not convicted or even prosecuted after he was found in contempt of congress a few years ago. While it is probably true that the DOJ Holder ran was unlikely to prosecute its boss for anything, and the DOJ Garland runs was happy and eager to prosecute Bannon for anything, this is not a clear case of a “two tiered” system of justice, one for Democrats and another for Republicans. Holder was a serving official in the executive branch and eligible to claim executive privilege, whether properly or as part of a cover up. Bannon had no such legal cover. Holder did cooperate in some ways with the committee investigating him. For a long time Bannon did not. Still he eventually did offer to testify, and one might have thought that offer would have made the citation for contempt moot. It seems unlikely that a Democrat behaving the same way would have been tried and very unlikely that he or she would have been sentenced to prison. (This conjecture may be tested next year when Republicans are running the investigations in congress.) I have no use for Bannon, but a person has to wonder if in this case his politics hurt him more than his conduct.

Labels: ,

Wednesday, August 19, 2020

Unprecedented for the Democrats?

 

Many conservatives, dismayed by what is happening in the Democratic Party, are warning  that it is an unprecedented shifting of the party to the left. I think they are wrong, not about the shifting but in thinking it is unprecedented.

Bernie Sanders is probably a worse human being than Henry Wallace (who accomplished some useful things before entering politics and finally turned against the communists), but he is no more a friend of and apologist for Soviet communism  that Wallace was in his time in politics, and Wallace made it to vice president. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is nothing new for the Democrats. She is just a more telegenic Bella Abzug.  Karen Bass is probably no bigger a fan of Fidel Castro than was Ron Dellums.   Some of the things McGovern and his people were advocating in 1972 are well to the left of what  the Dems are proposing now, as were many of the plans and actions of the New Dealers.  

 The Democrats have had their leftists for decades, and at various times, as now, the leftists have had significant influence in or even control of the party.  Of course not all Democrats are leftists. Both major parties have a diversity of opinions and ideologies among their members. Sometimes more moderate and less authoritarian people have been in charge, but the leftist authoritarianism has always been present and important in the modern party. It is the main reason Democrats are rarely the lesser evil in elections. It is the reason they are not the lesser evil this year, even against Donald Trump.

 

Labels: ,

Friday, August 14, 2020

No Longer Caring?

 

Arthur Koestler wrote that after the nonaggression pact, he no longer cared whether Hitler’s allies called him a counterrevolutionary.   We may be  getting to a point where many people in this country decide they no longer care whether the allies of America hating looters and arsonists call them racists. It would be a good thing,  That trick and threat of the left has provided cover for a lot of wrong thinking, false claims, and bad actions.

We have scoundrels preaching that individualism, rationality and objectivity, a belief in hard work, self reliance, planning for the future, civility, and respect for the property of others are “white male” traits, inappropriate for and deleterious to non- whites and getting their actual racist nonsense accepted in surprising places including the Smithsonian. We have “educators” indoctrinating  white children to feel guilty because of their race. We have attacks on people such as Thomas Jefferson, when in fact Jefferson is honored for his achievements and his ideas and principles, not for his failures to live up to them.  We have demands for reparations to black people for slavery  which have  no more sense or justification than would an ultimatum  from today’s Englishmen to Italians for a payoff for Caesar’s conquest. We have assertions of white privilege and systematic anti-black racism when the main systems  in government,  education,  and corporations  are explicitly structured  for black privilege through affirmative action quotas, lower admission standards, contract set asides, and so on.

Most important we have a pervasive attempt to make white Americans accept undeserved guilt.  The leftists want to make people feel guilty to make them easier to rule. That is the game, and people need to refuse to play it.  No one alive today had anything to do with slavery. No one under the age of seventy eight could have voted for the politicians who supported and protected Jim Crow laws before they were abolished in 1964. There are anti-black (and anti-Asian, anti-white, anti-Semitic, anti-Hispanic, and other) bigots and racists in the country. Most white people are not among them. There should be  no reason for any innocent person to accept a clearly false accusation, feel a need to refute it, or even become uneasy because of it. Instead people should stop caring what present day despicable and dishonest enemies of a liberal society say about them and either ignore it or tell them to go to hell  - or a polite equivalent of course.

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, August 05, 2020

More From Trump

Donald Trump is a jackass who has no business being president of the United States. Of the sixteen other people who sought the Republican nomination in 2016,  at least fourteen would have been a better choice, and an easy half dozen would have been a far better choice.  Republicans have a lot to answer for for the way they picked their candidate that year. He was elected only because the Democrats nominated someone who was worse – both as a candidate with plans and objectives and as a human being.

In the last week he has given the country two more example of how unfit for the job he is. In one of his tweets he outrageously suggested postponing the election because of the epidemic.  This country has never postponed and election, and a president has no power to postpone one. The country held the presidential election of 1864 during  a bloody rebellion and civil war. It held the presidential election of 1944 during a world war.  If as seems likely,  Trump meant the tweet to be taken seriously, it shows his ignorance, arrogance, power mania, and contemptuous disregard for law, limited government, and the Constitution. If he was joking, as some Republicans have hopefully or nervously suggested, it shows a buffoonish lack of dignity and understanding of the need for powerful people to be careful and thoughtful in what they say.

He has since delivered more of the same by declaring that if he does not get his way on a moratorium on or a reduction of social security taxes, he has the power to suspend the tax by decree.  It is not unfair to wonder whether he has forgotten, never learned, or simply does not care that the Constitution gives the congress the power to determine taxes.

He is at least as arrogant and power hungry as his predecessor, and less smooth in how he goes about it. Unfortunately he is also the person one should hope wins the election in November. Instead of offering moderate proposals and plans, the Democrats have adopted a dangerous and harmful leftist agenda (and with a candidate who is likely demented to boot), making it necessary for people who believe in individual rights and limited government to oppose them. That means voting for Republicans and supporting Trump’s reelection as the lesser evil, because overall his policies have been and his proposals and plans are far better than those of the Democrats. It is a hell of a note, bit it is what we’ve got. Neither an Ike, nor a  JFK, nor a Reagan, nor even  a Dole or a Humphrey will on the ballot for either party.


Labels: , ,

Friday, July 31, 2020

Victims and Victims

Whatever one thinks about the appropriateness of the lock downs over  the epidemic, it is indisputable that they produced real victims – people whose businesses or livelihoods  were damaged or ruined,  dying people in nursing homes who spent their last days alone because they were locked away from their family and friends, sick people left to suffer because the surgery they needed was banned as elective, children  who coped  poorly with the disruption of their lives’ routines, and many others.

There are also phony victims – officials responsible for shutdowns with sad tales of being triggered by “hateful” criticism from unruly subjects rude enough not to like being pushed around.  As one example a transsexual official in Pennsylvania has made national news and gained sympathetic attention in the traditional media by whining that some people who don’t like the way the lock down has gone in that state have been mean by failing to respect that fact that he prefers to be seen as a woman, even going so far as to ridicule his pretense and call him “sir”.  That may have been bad manners.  It may have been rude, counterproductive, and beside the point of opposing  the lock down.  But that is all it was.  It did not make him a victim, any more than being called a fat lunatic makes Trump a victim.

I will save my sympathy for the real victims, and let the thin skinned politicians and bureaucrats suffer as they may.  It is healthy for the country for people to treat politicians and bureaucrats  as a class as objects of ridicule.  Besides Truman was right about heat and kitchens.


Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, March 04, 2020

Learning from Phoniness


It is not news that most politicians and their media flacks are phonies. They produce evidence of that routinely day by day. People are so used to it that many expect nothing else and scarcely notice it anymore.  However sometimes  our civil masters and their friends display their phoniness in ways that tell people something interesting.   

A few years ago in  the Kelo case, the  Supreme Court ruled  that it was permissible for state and local governments to seize people’s property through eminent domain and hand it over to  private individuals or companies the governments favored.  Republicans like to claim they are defenders of individual rights and opponents of arbitrary government power.  The decision gave them an opportunity to show it by passing legislation banning the practice- either directly or indirectly by withholding money from governments that did it.  They  controlled the White House and both houses of congress, but  no bill was passed. (The president did issue an executive order, but it had little effect.)  One does not have to be a cynic to wonder if that was because some important donors to the Republican party were wealthy real estate developers who preferred having a government steal property for them to having to acquire it through voluntary exchange. Whether or not that was the reason, their  behavior told people something worth learning.

A while back Hillary Clinton let a large cat out of the bag when she  explained that she left Margaret Thatcher out of her supposedly apolitical compendium of gutsy women because she did not approve of her politics. It has been obvious to some people for a long time that Clinton’s style of feminism is less about women’s independence, accomplishment, or gutsiness than about leftist politics, and that to people like her the lives and accomplishments  and gutsiness of women who do not fit the political mold are to be ignored or disparaged. Still it was useful  though  a little unusual for her to proclaim her phoniness directly, out loud, and in public, but she is neither as clever nor as shifty as her husband.
  
A few days ago Trump appointed Richard Grenell to be acting director of national intelligence.  He is the first openly homosexual person to  have a cabinet level position in the United States. Activists and people in the traditional media have generally seen such firsts as beneficial and important whether by football players, police chiefs, elected officials, or whatever. One might have expected a similar reaction here, but it did not happen. The obvious reason it didn’t is that Grenell has the wrong politics, and that to them breaking down barriers does not matter if the politically wrong sort of people are doing it. That too is useful information.

Labels: ,