Friday, March 05, 2021

Big Lies, Here and There

 A political big lie is first a lie told for political gain and second big -  a statement  that if true would have important consequences and implications for a society.  It is usually also big in another way -  that of  being  frequently and consistently repeated and claimed as fact by influential advocates and supporters of those telling it.  Big lies may be completely unconnected to anything in reality or have a superficial and irrelevant connection to something true which may make them seem more believable.  

The most recent political big lie is from the Republicans - Trump’s claim that he won the election in a landslide, but the Democrats stole it from him by changing millions of votes in voting machines, dumping hundreds of thousands of fake ballots in close states, counting hundreds of thousands of votes from dead people, illegal aliens, and  non-residents, and other forms of cheating.  He has been saying  it since the election without presenting any evidence to back it up. He has been joined by some Republican politicians and a high percentage of talk radio people and others in the conservative media. They have not given people any evidence either. It is true that Democrats like to cheat some in elections. It is a tradition with them. Robert Ingersoll was warning about it not too long after the Civil War.  That says nothing about whether they did  cheat  or even could have cheated in the ways Trump has claimed and is no excuse for someone falling for Trump’s lie.  People are right to see Trump’s behavior and that of his supporters in media and politics as outrageous, dangerous, and harmful to the country. According to polls millions of people who voted for Trump believe it and thus have been led to conclude at least for a while that the country’s politics are rigged and its government is illegitimate. Thousands of people who believed it wasted their time and money coming to Washington on January 6th to demonstrate their belief, and a couple of hundred or so of them rioted and attacked the Capitol.

However Trump and company are not alone in their demagoguery. Democrats have  their own big lies.  One  is the  apocalyptic take on climate change – the claim that unless Democrats are given vast new powers over people’s lives, civilization and perhaps even human life will be destroyed by global warming in three, five,  or ten years. It is preached continually by  leftists, Democrats, and their public relations people in  the traditional media. There is no evidence for it, and the dates from past similar prophecies of climatic doom have passed unnoticed.  It is true that the general climate has gotten warmer over recent decades. It is also true that human produced carbon dioxide in the air contributes to that. That  does nothing to validate self-serving scare stories about the coming end of the world. This lie is outrageous, dangerous, and harmful to the country. Millions of people are said to believe it, and many of them are going through life worried and fearful, some  enough to be willing to accept any orders they might be given to save the planet and to demand that their neighbors do the same.

Another notable big lie of the Democrats is the claim that America is plagued by systematic anti-black racism. Even if one accepts that they do not mean racism in the literals sense of a belief that members of some racial groups are inherently superior or inferior to others solely because of their membership in the group,  but only racial bigotry or prejudice, it is still a lie, and those saying it have no evidence for it.  (Some of them  have more or less admitted this by resorting to  the easily refuted assertion that any statistical difference in anything between racial groups is evidence for racism.) The systems of government, colleges and universities, the traditional media, and large corporations are slanted in favor of black people through affirmative action quotas and set asides, lower admission standards, “diversity” training and  indoctrination, and a tendency to view and report things from the viewpoint of political correctness. Yet Democrats, leftists, and their friends in the traditional media make the claim  of systematic racism continually. It is true that there are plenty of anti-black bigots out there, and that some of them are cops who do bad things. It is surely true that the days of Jim Crow were an inexcusable national disgrace. That does nothing to validate assertions  of present day systematic racism.  The lie is outrageous, dangerous, and harmful to the country.  It increases hostility between racial groups, tells black people they cannot succeed in the world without being lifted by the benevolent hand of Democrat politicians, and tells white people they are worthless bigots, whether they know it or not, in an attempt to make them easier to rule.

A willingness by large numbers of people to accept big lies is a bad thing for a society, apart from the damage done by any particular big lie.   On the record of the success of the lies mentioned above, there is plenty of that willingness in the country these days.

Labels: , , , ,

Monday, September 23, 2019

Decency?


Young children are easily frightened.  They tend to believe what they are told. (Years ago my daughter spent a few days at her Montessori pre-school in stressful worry because one of the neighborhood brats had told her that her parents would drop her off at the school one day and never come back to get her. It was all we could do to get her to tell us what was bothering her.) Unnecessarily frightening a kid intentionally is repulsively wrong.  Doing so  and then exploiting that fear for some sort  of gain or advantage  is worse.  

That is what leftist politicians, school teachers, and media people are doing to children to promote and get publicity for their schemes to deal with “climate change”.  Whatever one thinks about  much the climate is warming and how much human activity is responsible for it, the world is not about to end. No Armageddon is upon us. We will not all be dead in one, ten, twelve or, according to some green prophecies, minus several   years.  Yet the lefties are scaring ignorant kids to death with apocalyptic nonsense and then using them as props for political theatre.

It is time to remember a question from history and ask  them “at long last, have you left no sense of decency?”.  On the evidence the answer would be no. They should be ashamed, and they certainly should be called out. Politics is a nasty game, and we should not expect its players to behave honestly or  honorably, but it is not too much to demand that they pick on people their own size and  leave the poor kids alone.

Labels: , , ,

Thursday, February 11, 2010

Warming's True Believers

We are now hearing from human-generated global warming’s journalistic true believers that recent blizzards are caused by global warming. Indeed for these people, whatever happens is caused by global warming, and nothing that happens or may happen can shake their faith. This is nothing new. One could substitute “angels” for “global warming” and have the same sort of all purpose explanation. After all, if angels by hypothesis can do anything, then anything that happens can be caused by them, and nothing that happens can cast doubt on the explanation. Similarly if every change in weather or climate is by hypothesis caused by global warming, then no observed facts or set of observed facts can cast doubt on that explanation.

This sort of thinking is commonplace and has been throughout history. It is not, however, scientific. There is a good reason that critics call this stuff a religion.

Labels: , , ,

Saturday, March 29, 2008

Global Warming

It is a good idea to start on global warming with what seems to be well known. Temperatures on average have been hotter in recent decades than they were in the 1700’s and early 1800’s at least in places where we have records to compare. The most recent complete decade, the 1990’s, was particularly warm. There is a known mechanism whereby carbon dioxide in the air can contribute to warming. Throughout the last hundred and fifty years people have discharged large and usually increasing amounts of carbon dioxide into the air by burning large amounts of coal and petroleum products.

Combining these facts, it is natural to conclude that the carbon dioxide so produced has contributed to the trend to higher temperatures. And in fact there seems to be a fairly broad agreement among informed people that such is the case.

The next question of course is how large a contribution. Is the carbon dioxide from burning the sole cause of the change in climate? Is it a largely insignificant input to a trend driven by other and weightier factors? Or is it something in between? It is here that the legitimate controversy begins.

However, before talking about the legitimate controversy, it is interesting to talk about the political controversy, which is something else entirely. Opinions there range from those who are certain that human actions are not only the sole cause of the warming but in fact the only possible cause to those who dismiss the entire notion of warming as a hoax or worse. Throughout the rants and discussions, axes are ground, logs are rolled, and very little is said that is useful.

One reason for this is that neither side has a whole lot of credibility.

On the right many of the conservatives who are skeptical about global warming seem indifferent or hostile to science as such. Some of these, for example, also oppose evolution and favor notions such as creation science. Others project their disagreement with leftist policies on warming back onto the question of warming itself. It can be hard to put much trust in their scientific objectivity.

On the left you have first a large number of people who so deeply want it to be true, whose yen to regulate and control their fellow citizens’ lives is so great, that they will grab onto anything that might offer them a supposed justification for their desire, be it global warming or whatever. Then you have those who have been pulpit thumping evangelists for every bogus impending ecological apocalypse of the last forty years and have learned nothing from being wrong so often. (Even if one is afraid that the sky might fall in, he probably doesn’t want to rely on Chicken Little for the news.) Finally you have the anointed spokesman for the left’s position Al Gore – a sufficiently, consistently mendacious ignoramus that, if he were to call Brittney Spears a silly slut, reasonable people might feel compelled to at least consider the hypothesis that she is a fine and gracious lady, unfairly maligned in the press. It can be hard to put much trust in their scientific objectivity also.

So the political arguments have mainly only entertainment value.

As to the real question of how much our burning of fuels contributes to warming, I don’t know, and I don’t expect ever to know. There are two reasons for this. First it seems to be a big, hard problem that is more likely to have a statistical and probabilistic answer or set of answers than a definite one. Second, and more important, I do not know whom to trust.

Very few people are experts on, say, quantum electrodynamics or the molecular biology of enzymes or the detailed nuances of paleontology. Almost nobody is an expert on all of them. If a reasonable non-expert gets curious about one of them or some other scientific theory, he finds a good source and reads about it at a technical or popular level appropriate to his interest and background and then usually believes the results at least tentatively and provisionally -- not because he has studied every bit of data and verified every inference and calculation – but because they make sense to him and because of a broad and justified belief in the way science works. He assumes that others have studied all the data and verified the conclusions, that this has been done more than once and sometimes by people other than the authors of the theory, and that in the main those involved have behaved honestly and objectively with truth as their first objective. When he looks at a subject where there are competing theories he behaves in a similar way, looking at accounts of the different explanations, perhaps reaching a (usually very tentative) conclusion about which theory is the most plausible and best supported, acting on an assumption of the general scientific integrity of the people and processes involved . Since no one has time to become an expert on everything, this is a sensible way for people to behave.

It seems to me that this is what I cannot do on the question of how much of the warming is caused by burning fuels. I cannot do it, because the involvement of the politicians and their friends has so polluted things that I do not feel justified in assuming people’s scientific honesty and objectivity. There are too many incentives and opportunities for shading, slanting, and manipulating data and results. I really believe that it would be necessary to review the data, check the code and assumptions of the computer models, and analyze darn near everything involved oneself before reaching a defendable conclusion. That is more nearly a career than a desultory afternoon or two of study. So for now I am resigned to being permanently agnostic.

As to policy, even if burning fuels caused all the recent warming, it would in no sense justify the sort of fascistic control over the lives of others that some leftists want. On the other hand there are good and well known reasons to move away from dependence on oil, irrespective of whether the climate warms or cools or why it does. If the flap over warming helps us move to using other sources of energy in an intelligent and sensible way, we will be better off for it.

Labels: ,