Tuesday, July 01, 2014

Rain and schools

We in West Texas have gone through several years of drought lately, though many of us have seen a good deal of rain in the last six weeks. Before the rains started there were cases around the area of politicians organizing citizens to pray for rain.  It seems that a large number of our adult citizens believe that changes in the weather – particularly rain storms -  are caused by supernatural forces.  Some may find this fact and others like it (including the gullibility of followers of the green religion in accepting their myths about climates) a cause for concern about the quality of the American electorate and what that might mean for the future, and they would be right to worry.


However, I thought instead about what it says about the quality of America’s government schools. Most adult Americans have done a twelve or thirteen year stretch in a government school. Surely at some point during their time in school, many or most sat through courses in science where some  general notions of the actual causes of atmospheric phenomena would have been mentioned. Yet the instruction seems not to have worked. (There was even a poll a while back reporting a large fraction of American adults did not know the earth orbited the sun.) Similar ignorance of history, English usage and composition, and basic arithmetic appears to be common. It would be unfair to blame the schools for  the ignorance of the  mentally deficient or completely unwilling, but these exceptions cover only so much. These schools are failing far too many people, and especially failing the people who need them most, and thus failing this country. Reform and competition are well over due. 

Labels: , ,

Thursday, February 20, 2014

Don't Know Much About Much

A recent poll of Americans had one fourth of its respondents stating they did not know the earth orbits around the sun. Another poll found that forty percent of Americans do not know which foreign powers the United States fought against in World War II. Almost one hundred percent of Americans  attend schools, mainly government schools, and over eighty five percent of  adult Americans have high school diplomas. It makes one wonder exactly the “educators” employed by government schools were doing with their charges for twelve or thirteen years of their lives.  If such high percentages of the inmates at  these schools finished their time without learning such basic facts, one has to wonder what else  they missed.  Similar polls and surveys, coupled with really dismal results of many widely used tests, suggest far too many students miss out on far too much at government schools, particularly those schools serving largely poorer people, and most particularly those serving poor black and Hispanic people. Thirteen years are a long time, longer than many prison sentences or corporate careers. To see so many people getting so little from so much time spent is sad and infuriating. 

This  is of course not news, and one did not need the two polls mentioned above to know it.  The overall performance of government schools is a national disgrace, one masked somewhat in public discussions because many talented and successful people of the sort who drive and participate in public discussions see their children developing well, and give the schools credit for that development, when, in fact, their children would probably do well with almost any type of schooling, including the one room school house. More meaningful metrics would measure how well the schools do with average students and students from difficult backgrounds, and that answer would be not well at all.

 Politicians pretend to care about all this, but there is no evidence they are serious. Democrats tend to want more money for their constituents employed by government schools, but seem uninterested in improvements.  Republicans often want more local control, but seem uninterested as well in making improvements, perhaps because many of the worst schools are in places where there are few people who vote for Republicans.

An obvious first step  toward improvement would be to admit that the failures and problems of government schools are not unique to them but rather particular instances of the failures and problems of government enterprises in general.  Socialized enterprises do not work well, as experience and sound economic reasoning show. As many people have said, whatever the case for governments’ funding the schooling of children, there is not much of a case for governments’ providing it as a near monopoly, apart from its having been  done that way for a long while. 

Experience and sound economic reasoning also show that competition among providers of goods and services tends to offer purchasers better and less costly products. If we are to keep funding schooling with taxes, but wish to  introduce competition, then vouchers of one form or another would be an obvious method to try. Employees of government schools  oppose vouchers emphatically, but rarely candidly. Their arguments that vouchers would benefit mainly rich  people by allowing them to move their children out of government schools are specious.   Wealthy parents already have options for schooling their kids outside of government schools, and everyone knows it. It is the parents of poor parents who have no outside options for their children at present and would have with vouchers. They, along with families with middle sized incomes who might be able to afford other choices but only with difficulty, are the main beneficiaries of vouchers. I believe the real reason for opposing vouchers is simpler. The people on  the payrolls of government schools fear they would be unable to compete for the parents’ dollars. It is not unfair to suppose that the reason for such fear is an understanding that their product is not good enough to attract paying customers.


I believe we need to overcome this opposition. Doing so will help  children from all backgrounds  -  those from poor or difficult backgrounds probably the most. This may be the best way to start to help large numbers of such children improve themselves and their situations in life, and one which probably will shrink government and control costs as well. 

Labels: , , ,