Wednesday, August 07, 2019

Nonsense about El Paso and Dayton


There is a lot of predictable nonsense going around after the shootings in El Paso and Dayton. In the first place, the only ones to blame are the two  who did the shooting. The facts that  one of them did not like immigration and the other supported Elizabeth Warren are irrelevant in terms of responsibility for what happened, and attempts to claim otherwise are absurd. So are efforts to blame video games, the NRA, the decline of religion, liberal social attitudes, conservative social attitudes, public schools, Republicans, Democrats, global warming,  or anything else except the choices and actions of two bad, deranged people (and their accomplices if any turn up). 

There is also the silly spectacle of opportunistic politicians running around declaring that a crisis is upon us, and they are just the boys and girls to pull us out of it. In fact mass shootings of random strangers, as separate from multiple homicides in domestic disputes or conflicts between rival groups of criminals, though horrible events,  are so rare as to be insignificant  in terms of life’s risks.  They are a small fraction of the total number of murders in the country, and the probability of becoming a victim of one is very close to zero.  Any efforts to “do something” to prevent murders would be far more effectively spent in working to lessen the larger dangers people face routinely in many parts of the country’s large cities. 

Of course one of the somethings some politicians want to do is use the crimes as a possible opportunity  for disarming private citizens.  So it is worth remembering that the right to self defense is a right, not a favor bestowed on the proles by their rulers, contingent on no crooks or psychopaths ever doing anything bad with a gun.  

Labels: ,

Monday, November 27, 2017

Crimes and Other Things

There are crucial distinctions separating  crimes, actions creating a civil liability, and simply sleazy or disgusting behavior. It is important to resist tendencies to blur or ignore them - whether by making crimes out of non-crimes, excusing bad actions  because they fall short of being criminal, or something else.  

 Taking examples from the news,  if Harvey Weinstein raped any of the women who say he did, he is a criminal and should be prosecuted as one.  If he went against policies or mutual understandings on harassment  in his treatment of women working or wanting to work at his  movie company, he  is liable to lawsuits for doing so. In the unlikely case he did neither but only behaved  for years as a crude, overbearing,  obnoxious lecher, he is still a lowlife whose company decent people might want to shun, but not someone who should be hauled into civil or criminal court.  If Kevin Spacey attacked and  tried to sodomize a fourteen year old boy, he is a criminal and deserving of prosecution (deserving even  if that is impossible due a statute of limitations). If he harassed fellow actors on the job, he is fair game for lawsuits. If he did neither but continually hustles and propositions the legal age men he meets socially without respect to their interests or inclinations, he is still a very  unpleasant character but not someone who belongs in court. If in his thirties Roy Moore felt up a fourteen year old girl, he is a criminal pervert who should be prosecuted (should even though can’t due to a statute of limitations).  If in his thirties he only trolled malls for and  tried to date legal age teenage girls, he is a creepy guy one would not want to hang out with but not someone who should be in court.

Not every bad action is a crime or even a tort. There are many things one  should disapprove of or condemn which are not matters for the government or the  law but rather for individual judgments base on one’s sense of decency and propriety.  


    

Labels: , ,