Wednesday, October 31, 2018

A Close Call


There is a long history of  unreasonable  things  being said and written about evolution.  Most have come from people who believed the Biblical story of creation was true.  These days such people are often called young earth creationists, because of their beliefs that the earth and the cosmos are only about six thousand years old and that present day humans and animals have lived on the earth since its creation. Lately there have been examples of a different sort from a different source -  “progressive”   people who deny the evolutionary bifurcation into  two sexes and claim that gender is a social construct rather than a  genetically determined fact.  It is interesting to speculate on which group is behaving more irrationally. On the surface it would seem to be  the new earthers,  since they deny that evolution happened at all while the advocates of gender fluidity deny only that it turned out as it really did.  However the things the young earthers are denying are not immediately obvious and require study and reflection  to understand,  while the things the  gender fluid people denying  are  plainly observable in the ordinary course of life.  It would be a close call as to which bunch is being less rational, and one would hate to have to live on the difference.

Labels: , , ,

Tuesday, January 26, 2016

Greens and Evolution

It is commonplace for leftists to accuse conservatives of ignorance of and hostility toward science – of being “anti science” as they often put it. They usually and with good reason cite some conservatives’ attitudes toward evolution as evidence for their charge.  However leftists, at least the green ones, are by no means innocent of mythological thinking  on the same subject.

While some religious conservatives deny that evolution has occurred,  many greens accept that it has but demand that it now stop and claim that they have both the ability and a moral imperative to make it stop. They see the  distribution of species and individuals and the level of human activity of the present day, or of somewhere around 1800, or, for the more fervid, of the Middle Ages or  Neolithic times as an ideal  state which must be preserved or restored and  then shielded from change.  (Amusingly this in a way makes them conservatives or reactionaries in the old fashioned sense of those terms.)

This of course is quite unscientific.  Evolution cannot be stopped. It will continue. Environments will change. Some things will thrive, and others will decline. Species will become extinct, and new species will evolve. Humans participate in some of the processes, but cannot bring  them all to an absolute halt. The notion of an intrinsically ideal state of things ordained by Nature is not science but rather a manifestation of the romantic longings and/or resentments of those embracing it.  It is also another reason for considering the green movement to be a religion.


There is plenty of unscientific thinking going  around in a variety of places, and the leftists have less room than they think for being smug about the situations.   

Labels: , ,

Sunday, August 23, 2015

Why Do They Bother?

I recently stumbled across an article on the internet presenting a new – at least to me – fallback position of the creationists of the sort who like to be called “creation scientists” in their attacks on evolution. It consists of grudgingly  accepting the evidence us of evolutionary change on short time scales within species (sometimes called microevolution) while rejecting the notion of evolutionary change on longer time scales producing new species (sometimes called macroevolution).  The article supported the assertion with a vigorous claim that neither laboratory observations nor fossil records provide  evidence of intermediate stages between species, and thus macroevolution is only a shaky hypothesis and wishful thinking.

I found this interesting, not because of the claims,  which are specious, but because I wondered why the people  bother to make them at all when I can see no gain for them in it.  Imagine for a moment that their objections are valid, and that the data provide insufficient evidence to support the present notions of mechanisms  for macroevolution. It wouldn’t do them any real good.

After all the same data, which by their using it to make their point  they can be  presumed to take as valid, show clearly  that the Biblical version of the origin of the species is false.  That leaves  the creationists who accept the data   in the difficult position of explaining why a god who must be presumed to know how he created the species decided to give his chosen people a false account of the way  it happened. While that might be capable of being finessed in some way, but there is a more serious difficulty.  All that a rejection of currently understood mechanisms  of macroevolution would mean is that something else goes on in the process of originating new  species which we haven’t found out about. It would not change the evidence otherwise, and it in no way  would require the intervention of gods of any sort, much less the particular god the creationists have in mind. They still would have no evidence for their “science”.


That’s why I wonder why they bother. They probably would be better off emotionally in some ways to throw in with  fundamentalists and  simply  say the Biblical version of things is correct, and evidence be hanged. Of course there is the hypothesis that that is what they are really doing anyway at some level, and all the so-called creation science talk is just a smokescreen. 

Labels: ,